Book Review: Whole Earth Discipline
Permalink +Fri, Jul 16, 2010, 4:44 am // Guest writer
Whole Earth Discipline: An Ecopragmatist Manisfesto by Stewart BrandEric Hirst is guest writer.
Environmental Heretic or Prophet? A Review of Stewart Brand’s Whole Earth Discipline: An Ecopragmatist Manifesto, Viking Press, 2009.
Stewart Brand’s new book shakes the foundation of conventional environmental thinking. I moved to California in 1964 to attend graduate school. That summer I hiked in Yosemite National Park and instantly became an environmentalist. Like many others, my environmental interests evolved over the following decades. Initially, my goal was to preserve western high-altitude wilderness areas (rocks and ice.) My horizons later expanded to include air pollution, water pollution, and toxic wastes. Much of my career at Oak Ridge National Laboratory focused on energy efficiency, primarily to reduce the use of fossil fuels and the environmental problems associated with their extraction, transportation, and combustion. Now global warming looms over everything else, the ultimate game changer.
Along comes Stewart Brand with a book on global warming and strategies to respond. Brand, now in his early 70s, is best known for his Whole Earth Catalog, published from 1968 to 1985. His new book challenges many conventional environmental beliefs. Because the author is a well-recognized environmentalist, we need to take seriously his criticisms of the environmental establishment and his suggestions. The book has chapters on population, urbanization, nuclear energy, genetic engineering, and geo-engineering.
Climate change is unlike other environmental problems in its magnitude, both scope and scale. It affects the entire planet, not just local regions. And it promises to change dramatically life on earth. Environmentalists traditionally worried about the effects of people and our technologies on the environment; with global climate change we are now worried about the effects of the earth on us.
Many environmentalists (including me) believe that population growth lies at the root of all major environmental problems. Unless we can slow and then stop population growth, all is lost because increases in the number of people will overwhelm all efforts to manage the commons and cut pollution.
Brand has a different take on the issue. Largely because of increasing urbanization, population growth is slowing dramatically. As more and more people move to cities, they choose to have fewer children. Indeed, within a few decades we will have a declining world population.
Urbanization is good for the environment, according to Brand. Getting people out of the countryside allows the rural landscape to recover. In addition, cities are where innovation occurs and new ideas are born. Brand is upbeat about the slums in large third-world cities, which he says are hotbeds of creativity.
Brand says that nuclear energy must be a key part of our energy mix. Most renewables are intermittent (e.g., solar and wind,) which limits their usefulness to the electrical grid. Electricity is the ultimate real-time product, produced at exactly the same time it is consumed, because the electrical system has almost no storage capacity. Nuclear power is reliable, controllable, and its production costs are very low. It provides baseload power that runs steadily 24/7.
Brand says we should not worry about the long-term (thousands of years) storage of nuclear waste. We should plan to store such wastes for about a century and assume that the creativity and new technologies invented by our children and grandchildren will solve the long-term waste-storage problem. Had environmentalists been unsuccessful in blocking nuclear plants, we would have a lot fewer coal plants—and therefore much less carbon dioxide, sulfur and nitrogen air pollution, and land and streams ruined by mountaintop removal and strip mining.
Concerns about genetically engineered foods (frankenfood) are seriously misplaced. The environmental community should learn more about biology so it understands the major benefits these modified foods bring to society, including much less use of pesticides and fertilizers. Brand says the environmental community has “starved people, hindered science, hurt the natural environment, and denied our own practitioners a crucial tool” in opposing genetic engineering.
Brand sees the environmental movement made up of Romantics and Scientists. “The romantics identify with natural systems; the scientists study natural systems.” A new set of players is emerging—engineers who want to fix things. And global warming is a gigantic problem in search of lots of fixes. “Romantics love problems; scientists discover and analyze problems; engineers solve problems.”
Brand favors further study of and experimentation with new ideas to modify the earth’s climate, called geoengineering. These are efforts to directly modify the earth’s climate and slow (or reverse) global warming. The leading scheme involves stratospheric sulfates. Much as a volcano would, we could inject sulfates directly into the atmosphere. Airplanes, cannons, or balloon-suspended hoses could be used to deliver the sulfates.
Brand’s book includes an excellent list of books and papers on science, climate, cities, population, nuclear, genetic engineering, environmentalism, ecology, Indians, restoration, and geoengineering.
Brand is too much of a technological optimist. He believes we will identify and invent new technologies and systems to solve the problems caused by global warming. He also believes (implicitly) that these new technologies will have no serious adverse side effects. I disagree with both of his beliefs. However, this is such an interesting, wide-ranging, and well-written book that I urge you to read it.
Editor note: This book is currently in stock and on the shelves at Village Books. July 15
Comments (1)
To add a comment, click here to login or register.
Steve Wilson // Mon, Jul 19, 2010, 8:08 am
Thanks for the book review Eric. Sounds very interesting. I would agree that Stewart is overly optomistic. Is he suggesting that we are no longer under the spell of Alfred E. Newman: “What Me Worry?”
Why is it that it’s more popular to believe we can solve all these man-made problems instead of avoiding their creation. Seems like a convenient form of denial.
BTW, have you read ‘The Report From Iron Mountain’ (from the 60’s)?
Book Review: Whole Earth Discipline
Fri, Jul 16, 2010, 4:44 am // Guest writer
Eric Hirst reviews this October 2009 book by Stewart Brand of Whole Earth Catalog fame. Stewart is critical of several mainstream environmental stances.
1 comments; last on Jul 19, 2010
The Way I See It - From Russia with Love
Wed, Jul 14, 2010, 5:17 pm // Ham Hayes
Ham's final post on his travel comments from Russia.
0 comments
Climate and transparent process
Wed, Jul 14, 2010, 11:52 am // John Servais
The Atlantic Monthly has an article on Climate gate that every Enviro true believer should read. Some healthy skepticism is very needed.1 comments; last on Jul 17, 2010
Oil Spill - What is not reported
Mon, Jun 28, 2010, 1:17 pm // John Servais
BP oil spill video taken on a private plane flight over the Gulf of Mexico. The spill is worse than our media are telling us.
0 comments
Please sign the anti-whaling petition
Thu, Jun 17, 2010, 11:31 pm // John Servais
Let's help get one million signatures on the anti-whaling petition.1 comments; last on Jun 20, 2010
Shame on Israel
Mon, May 31, 2010, 7:43 pm // John Servais
Israel is becoming a rogue state. It is showing a disdain for International law and world opinion.13 comments; last on Jun 03, 2010
Re-Legalize Cannabis and End an Un-American Prohibition
Sun, May 23, 2010, 11:37 am // Guest writer
David Camp writes on Prohibition and the American Way3 comments; last on May 28, 2010
Spaghetti Reasoning on Climate
Mon, Apr 05, 2010, 4:30 pm // John Servais
Greenpeace has more empty threats for anyone who doesn't believe as they do. Guess they are going to cut off NwCitizen funding.2 comments; last on Apr 07, 2010
The Way I See It - Cranes and cows
Wed, Mar 31, 2010, 4:59 am // Ham Hayes
Sandhill Cranes: the Columbia River Basin's swallows of Capistrano
0 comments
The Way I See It - Choose your poison
Wed, Mar 10, 2010, 4:49 am // Ham Hayes
How we, the public, choose to respond to growing polarization in our society is crucial.1 comments; last on Mar 10, 2010
Fair Sports are the only way
Mon, Feb 15, 2010, 4:49 am // John Servais
Larry Ellison has won the America's Cup in sailing by playing fair. He is a fine example for us all.0 comments
The Way I See It - Decade “Change”
Wed, Dec 30, 2009, 7:00 am // Ham Hayes
Paul Krugman of the New York Times calls the now departing decade, “Decade Zero.” My wife and I are traveling this week to visit three…1 comments; last on Dec 30, 2009
The Way I See It - Season’s Greetings
Wed, Dec 16, 2009, 7:00 am // Ham Hayes
It’s the Season. As a country and a society we come from many diverse cultures and belief systems. And few other countries in the world…0 comments
FTC workshop - Journalism in the Internet Age
Thu, Dec 03, 2009, 10:00 pm // John Servais
The FTC workshop webcasts are posted and available for viewing. FTC workshop - How will Journalism Survive the In9 comments; last on Dec 04, 2009
The Way I See It - Los Angeles Resurrected
Wed, Nov 25, 2009, 7:00 am // Ham Hayes
I’ve been to Los Angeles many times. I even remember the Red and Yellow electric street cars that served the city from after World War…
0 comments
The Radical Center and the Outer Limits
Fri, Nov 20, 2009, 9:06 am // Paul de Armond
Did you every wonder what was really going on inside the racist right? Usually caricatured by stereotypes of bed-sheeted Klansmen and goose-stepping neo-Nazis, the racist…
8 comments; last on Dec 04, 2009
The Way I See It - The State
Wed, Nov 04, 2009, 7:00 am // Ham Hayes
Few of us advocate for the suppression of the human spirit. In fact we would be shocked if others characterized us as miserly, mean spirited…
1 comments; last on Nov 04, 2009
Highly disturbing
Fri, Sep 25, 2009, 2:56 pm // John Servais
These photos are from a video taken at the G-20 protests in Pittsburgh. Why are unidentified, Army-fatigue-wearing men very forcibly taking a protester and jamming…
10 comments; last on Sep 26, 2009
Who does what, now, how?
Fri, May 22, 2009, 9:35 pm // Guest writer
We have a guest article to start our Memorial Day weekend. Marian Beddill has a philosophical fable for us to read and, she hopes, post…11 comments; last on Jun 02, 2009
Consuming earth’s assets
Wed, May 20, 2009, 11:25 am // Larry Horowitz
“At present, we are stealing the future, selling it in the present, and calling it gross domestic product.” So says renowned entrepreneur and visionary Paul…1 comments; last on May 21, 2009
Watching the Space Station
Fri, Apr 24, 2009, 6:04 pm // John Servais
We expect to have clear or almost clear skies at dawn for the next few days. And, as chance would have it, the ISS -…
1 comments; last on Apr 24, 2009
Obama Administration is Naive
Tue, Mar 17, 2009, 11:30 pm // John Servais
The AIG bonuses are an outrage and all of America - left and right - feels this way. The news we have been reading from…10 comments; last on Mar 18, 2009
Moron Money
Sun, Mar 15, 2009, 4:25 pm // g.h.kirsch
"I place economy among the first and most important virtues, and public debt as the greatest of dangers. To preserve our independence, we must not…
6 comments; last on Mar 17, 2009
Barack Obama is President
Tue, Jan 20, 2009, 1:22 pm // John Servais
Americans and people all around the world celebrate. We celebrate that a black man has transcended our national racism. But more than 80% of Americans…4 comments; last on Jan 20, 2009
Where Do You Draw the Line
Thu, Dec 11, 2008, 10:46 pm // Craig Mayberry
Another day another bailout by our government. After facing fierce opposition from regular people, our federal government decided to bail out banks, now the latest…7 comments; last on Dec 12, 2008
Obama Wins - YaaahHoooo
Tue, Nov 04, 2008, 9:02 pm // John Servais
- Additional paragraph added Wed morn at bottom. We watched it being inevitable for the last hour - and now the networks are declaring Barack…15 comments; last on Nov 07, 2008
Barack Obama - our best hope
Sun, Nov 02, 2008, 2:10 pm // John Servais
Barack Obama probably will win Washington State's 11 electoral votes. But he will only win if all of us who favor him actually vote for…
11 comments; last on Nov 02, 2008
The Political Elite Don’t Get It
Sun, Aug 31, 2008, 4:44 pm // Craig Mayberry
{Please read this post in the spirit it is intended, somewhat satirical and a little exaggerated at times to make a point often missed in…21 comments; last on Aug 31, 2008
War and Information control
Mon, Aug 11, 2008, 2:03 pm // John Servais
The power of censorship and news control is on display for all who care to look around. Today, the online maps of the country of…
5 comments; last on Aug 12, 2008
Magnetism & the search for unlimited energy
Sat, Jun 28, 2008, 7:11 am // Larry Horowitz
On March 26, 2002, the US Patent Office issued Patent No. 6,362,718 B1, potentially altering the entire paradigm in our quest for the holy grail…11 comments; last on Jun 30, 2008
The Clintons: I suddenly have a problem
Sat, Jan 26, 2008, 2:18 pm // John Servais
Below is a link to an opinion piece in today's Los Angeles Times. It is written by a liberal - obviously a Democrat - and…1 comments; last on Jan 26, 2008
LWV Immigration Forum
Tue, Jan 22, 2008, 1:07 pm // Craig Mayberry
Although technically immigration is a national issue, there are implications for Whatcom County due to the heavy agricultural base and proximity to the border. The…0 comments
NwCitizen 1995 to 2008
Early Northwest CitizenNew
Citizen TedSkookum.us
WikiLeaks.org
Current Interest
Auditor election pageSkookum.us
WA State Elections
Local
Bellingham HeraldBham Politics & Economics
Bob Sanders
Carl Weimer
Cascadia Weekly
Citizen Ted
Ferndale R-J
Foothills Gazette
John Watts
KGMI
Latte Republic
Lynden Tribune
Mainstreampolitics
Northern Light
Northwest Review
Sam Taylor
Skookum.us
Twilight Zoning
Wally Wonders
Washington Outsiders
Western Front - WWU
Whatcom Watch
Local causes
Bham CofC political blogChuckanut Mountains
Citizens of Bellingham
City Club of Bham
Conservation NW
Cordata & Meridian
Futurewise - Whatcom
Lake Whatcom
N. Cascades Audubon
N. Sound Conservancy
Neighborhood Schools Coalition
No Leaky Buckets
NW Holocaust Center
RE Sources
Skookum.us
Transition Whatcom
WA Conservation Voters
Local Leisure
Adventures NWEntertainment NNW
Climate & Weather
Climate AuditWatts Up With That?
Weather by Cliff Mass
Cascadia
Crosscut SeattleJoel Connelly
Orcinus
Portland Indy Media
Seattle Indy Media
Washington Votes
Leisure
Am Cup - GGYC viewAm Cup legal fight
Worth checking out
Al-Jazeera onlineAlaska Dispatch
AlterNet.org
Antiwar.com
Arab News
Asia Times
Atlantic, The
Buzz Flash
Common Dreams
counterpunch
Daily Beast, The
Daily Kos
Daily Mirror
Drudge Report
FiveThirtyEight
Foreign Policy in Focus
Guardian Unlimited
Gulf News
Haaretz
Huffington Post
Innocence Project, The
Intrnational Herald Tribune
James Fallows
Jerusalem Post
Juan Cole
Le Diplo
Media Matters
Middle East Times
MoveOn.org
Nation, The
New American Century
News Trust
NMFA
numbers
Online Journal
Palestine Daily
Palestine News
Personal bio info
Politico
Progressive Review
Project Vote Smart
Reuters
Sea Shepherd
Slate
Talking Points Memo
The Onion
Tom Paine.com
truthout
War and Piece
WikiLeaks.org
ynetnews.com
Governments
Auditor election pageBellingham
Bham - PFD
Skagit County
The White House
WA State Access
WA State Elections
WA State Legislature
Whatcom Auditor
Whatcom County
Other - for whatever
BushFlash.comChickehhawks
Doonesbury
George Bush
Info Clearing House
Michael Moore
Reality News
The Crisis Papers
Third World Traveler
Unity08
Election 2009
- Candidate Forum - video- Mike McAuley endorsement
Bham #6 - Catherine Chambers
Bham #6 - Michael Lilliquist
Bham At Large - Orphalee
Bham At Large - Seth
County #1 - Dan McShane
County #1 - Kathy Kershner
County #2 - Ken Mann
County #2 - Mary B Teigrob
County #3 - Carl Weimer
County #3 - Michelle Luke
County At Large - Bill
County At Large - Laurie
Port #1 - John Blethen
Port #1 - Scott Walker
Port #2 - Doug Smith
Port #2 - Mike McAuley
2010 Winter Olympics
Amy Goodman InterrogationNo 2010 Olympics
No women ski jumpers
Olympics muzzle free speech
Olympics Resistance Network
Page of Links
Spectacle Vancouver
Zirin on Olympics
Less active
Eye on WhatcomPost-Oklahoman Confessions
The American Telegraph
Quiet, offline or dead
David HackworthGitmo prisoner 345
Mega Awesome
Not in my county
Parkenfarker
Pro-Whatcom