By: Wendy Harris (108)

Extracting Profit and Destroying Experience: The Waterfront Plan

• Topics:

There is very little to like about the COB waterfront plan, as far as substance or procedure.  And this, I believe, results from looking at the waterfront from an outdated economic paradigm where the focus is on extracting local experience.  According to research, today's tourist wants to spend money on an authentic and enhanced local experience.

Instead of giving up our public tidelands and access to water in exchange for crappy, dense, environmentally harmful shoreline development, more roads, traffic and blocked public views, we could have developed the nearshore and shoreline as an eco-tourism Mecca.

How practical is this?  According to WDFW, very.  Wildlife viewing is the #1 outdoor activity in the U.S., and the fastest growing form of recreation, exceeding hiking, skiing and golfing.  By necessity, it largely occurs on public land. WDFW concludes that wildlife watching is an untapped economic resource.

Over $1.7 billion is spent annually in Washington on wildlife watching activities, mostly in rural areas, supporting more than 21,000 jobs, making it second only to Boeing, and 5.2 times larger than Microsoft's employment in Washington. Wildlife watching yields $426.9 million in job income and generates $56.9 million in state and $67.4 million in federal tax revenues each year.

Compared to commodities, money spent on wildlife watching is second only to the combined value of all field crops. Its value is larger than the value of livestock; and larger than the combined value of all fruits, nuts and berries produced annually! 

We had the largest breeding colony of Caspian terns on the North American coast a few years ago. I say "had" because the port harassed the birds away from the waterfront site. (The same one we were told had zero ecological function so that any development was a net gain.) While they were here, people were traveling, by word of mouth alone, to see the birds, and scientists from Oregon came here to study them. 

How many urban creeks support spawning salmon, and the stealth harbor seals that slip in to take a big bite out of what a recreational fisherman has caught? Frustration for fisherman translates into delight for tourists, and more work for locals. And few shoreline parks allow people to observe harlequin ducks, Barrow's goldeneye, and playful otters within a relatively close range. 

We could have developed the waterfront as a natural shoreline, a sight more rare and precious than the usual waterfront development one finds in Puget Sound. The waterfront was already publicly owned, and we were already obligated to cleanup the contaminated sites.  We could have protected wildlife and habitat and provided the public with the parks they desired, all at a significantly reduced cost... so reduced, in fact, that no fire sale to developers would have been needed.  And perhaps that is exactly why this option was never on the table. 

How do you spell "missed opportunity?"

About Wendy Harris

Citizen Journalist • Member since Mar 31, 2008

Dick Conoboy

May 27, 2014

This article reminds me of my visit this Memorial Day weekend to the area around Monterrey, CA.  People flock to what used to be “Cannery Row” to visit shops selling cheap souvenirs and tacky clothing and dine (?) out at such wonderful places as Bubba Gump’s shrimp restaurant. At least they had the decency not to name the place Bubba Steinbeck’s.  The only saving grace is the Monterrey Aquarium.  Perhaps Bubba can set up shop here and peddle his “jumbo shrimp” in the shadow of the Granary Building.


Helen Brandt

May 27, 2014

Right on Wendy! My friends’ (transplanted escapees from southern California) favorite activity is walking the Squalicum Harbor dock and web locker areas to watch the fishing people working. Have we noticed how people gravitate to the undeveloped beach areas at the end of Cornwall Avenue and at Squalicum beach?  They sit staring out at the water and islands, watch the ducks, geese and seals, or walk at low tide looking for interesting items. Why would travelers from the land-locked Midwest want to spend their precious vacation time around high-rise condos, densely clustered upscale stores or hotels (think Bellwether) when they could watch real fishing and crabbing people at work. And have quiet space to watch the bay, wildlife, clouds and islands. Bellingham would be smart to not imitate other over-developed waterfront cities. The potential here is unique.


Tip Johnson

Jun 07, 2014

Don’t get me started on the waterfront plan.  It is an abject fraud that I seriously think a several folk ought to go to jail or at least lose their jobs over.

However, Wendy, I find you maybe the most valuable community resources for work like this.  You know where to find the line and are not afraid to cross it to make your points.  Obviously, that is going to draw some fire from time to time.

I hope you are circumspect enough to consider the source(s) and let the riff-raff’s drivel roll off your back like a well-preened duck.  Thanks again!


George Dyson

Jun 09, 2014

Not to mention that by de-authorizing Whatcom Waterway, we are rendering downtown bellingham forever inaccessible to the deep-draft (and even medium-draft) sailing vessels (and future hybrids)  that enabled downtown Bellingham to thrive in the first place, and, given the opportunity, might have done so again.


Barbara Perry

Jun 11, 2014

I agree with Helen Brandt:  “Right on Wendy!”  and Tip Johnson: “…Wendy, I find you maybe the most valuable community resources for work like this. “

You clearly state what I, as a life time Washington and Whatcom resident have always felt: “…we could [should] have developed the nearshore and shoreline as an eco-tourism Mecca…”
However Now we must look at ”…crappy, dense, environmentally harmful shoreline development, more roads, traffic and blocked public views.” 
Unfortunately, your words are too true for most of our council members to heed.
Thank you Northwest Citizen for publishing Wendy’s important articles.  I hear and hope Council members read NW Citizen and heed more of Wendy’s ecological advice

To comment, Log In or Register

Extracting Profit and Destroying Experience: The Waterfront Plan

By Wendy HarrisOn May 27, 2014

There is very little to like about the COB waterfront plan, as far as substance or procedure.  And this, I believe, results from looking at the waterfront from an [...]

5 comments, most recent 6 years ago

How Park Improvements Generate Heat

By Wendy HarrisOn May 26, 2014

Wedesday, May 28th, 6:30 p.m., at Bloedel Donovan Park Multipurpose Building there is a public meeting to discuss park improvements.  Park improvements include an expensive engineered stormwater system, and [...]

2 comments, most recent 6 years ago

The Trojan Slaughterhouse and the Scrivener’s Errors

By Wendy HarrisOn May 18, 2014

UPDATE:  The County Council sent out an email today pulling this matter from the Tuesday agenda.  We are advised this will be reset for a public hearing on [...]

3 comments, most recent 6 years ago

Bellingham’s 2013 Water Quality Report: The Facts But Not the Truth

By Wendy HarrisOn May 13, 2014

Great News!! According to Bellingham’s 2013 Safe Drinking Water Act annual water quality report, "Bellingham's water is very clean." Sure, "unregulated contaminants of concern" (vanadium, stontium, hexavalent chromium, [...]

1 comment, most recent 7 years ago

Action Alert for Tonight: Waterfront Wildlife and Habitat Threatened

By Wendy HarrisOn Apr 21, 2014

Previously, I discussed the problem with the habitat assessment needed for the Waterfront District before waterfront development occurs. Prior to the enactment of the [...]

Tell County To Expand Scope of EIS Review for Plants and Animals

By Wendy HarrisOn Apr 01, 2014

Please support county wildlife and habitat by asking the county to expand the scope of its Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) review of plants and animals. Under current plans, the county [...]

Public May Comment On EIS Scoping For County Comp. Plan Until April 7th

By Wendy HarrisOn Mar 31, 2014

On March 18, I attended a public hearing for the EIS scoping process on the county comprehensive plan update and was disappointed to see only a handful of people in attendance. [...]

My State of the Lake Report for 2014

By Wendy HarrisOn Mar 28, 2014

The latest annual Lake Whatcom monitoring report by Dr. Matthews indicates that we currently have the highest recorded levels of carcinogenic by-products in our treated drinking water.  This report [...]

2 comments, most recent 7 years ago

Propaganda Replaces Public Information:  An Analysis of the Lake Whatcom TDML Process

By Wendy HarrisOn Mar 17, 2014

The annual “state of the lake,” a meeting and public hearing regarding Lake Whatcom, is scheduled for March 26, 6 p.m. at Bellingham City Hall.  This is an [...]

4 comments, most recent 7 years ago

Action Alert for Tonight: Waterfront Wildlife and Habitat Not Being Protected as Promised

By Wendy HarrisOn Feb 24, 2014

Action Alert: I am requesting that people come to the city council meeting tonight, at 7p.m. to speak at open session regarding habitat connectivity and wildlife protection at the [...]

Wendy Harris on Citizen Journalism

By Wendy HarrisOn Feb 22, 2014

We had a fine dinner the evening of Feb 7 at the 'Back Alley' dining room of the Black Cat restaurant in Fairhaven.  The room was at capacity with an [...]

Bellingham Seeks “Flexibility” To Sell Wholesale Rural Sewer Services

By Wendy HarrisOn Feb 09, 2014

For the last week, public concern has increasingly focused on important agenda items that will be discussed by the Whatcom County Council this Tuesday.  I have come to understand [...]

3 comments, most recent 7 years ago

The Hidden Costs of Costco

By Wendy HarrisOn Feb 09, 2014

While the city will be celebrating an “unanticipated” financial windfall at its Monday council meeting, I will be mourning irretrievable loss. The city just received a grant of $2,225,000 [...]

1 comment, most recent 7 years ago

Have You Exceeded Your Right To Information?

By Wendy HarrisOn Feb 01, 2014

Did you know that we could “exceed our rights to information” by making too many public record requests, or making a request that was too broad, or making [...]

2 comments, most recent 7 years ago

Port Memo Addresses Marina Fraud Allegations

By Wendy HarrisOn Dec 20, 2013

 A recent Northwest Citizen article by Doug Karlberg,  asserting that the port tampered with consultant data to make the ASB facility the least expensive option for a marina, [...]

5 comments, most recent 7 years ago

Lummi Influence Over the Waterfront Planning Process Continues to Grow

By Wendy HarrisOn Dec 17, 2013

Today, the Department of Ecology (DOE) released a summary response to the public comments submitted for the Cornwall Avenue Landfill RI/FS review (the clean up process under the Model [...]

2 comments, most recent 7 years ago

On Monday, City Council Votes “third and final” Approval of Waterfront Plan

By Wendy HarrisOn Dec 07, 2013

Bellingham law requires a reconfirmation vote (known as the "third and final") before a prior vote (considered the "first and second") is considered final.  So the vote to approve [...]

2 comments, most recent 7 years ago

Lecture on County Water Issues Draws Crowd

By Wendy HarrisOn Dec 06, 2013

Timing is everything, and no where is this more evident than in Whatcom County’s water supply and demand problems.  We have a surplus of water in the [...]

3 comments, most recent 7 years ago

Waterfront Development Bonus Yet Another Bad Idea

By Wendy HarrisOn Nov 30, 2013

The proposed waterfront development standards provide developers with an option for an increased density bonus, known as the Floor Area Development Bonus, and on Monday afternoon, the Bellingham City Council [...]

1 comment, most recent 7 years ago

City and Port Ready To Act on Waterfront Plan

By Wendy HarrisOn Nov 29, 2013

The Bellingham City Council and the Port Commission will be taking action on the Waterfront District Sub Area Plan and related documents, amending the 2013 Shoreline Master Program to allow greater [...]

2 comments, most recent 7 years ago