About Letter Writer

We accept letters to the editor from our readers. View policies under "About" on the menu

By: Letter Writer (13)

Letter:  U.S. Senate

Randy Petty on the dysfunctional structure of the U.S. Senate.

Randy Petty on the dysfunctional structure of the U.S. Senate.

By
• Topics: USA & World,

A sound byte that won't die.

The sound byte is: "The U.S. Senate represents states, not people." 

So much could be said. Who elects Senators and who do they visit and talk to when they go home? People. What if a state has 3 people, or none? Do the Senators represent corn stalks and gopher holes?

The problem with two Senators per state regardless of population ( well, one of the problems ) is that it not only makes sure California doesn't dictate to Wyoming, it makes sure that smaller state senators can dictate to the whole country. Senate actions are largely national.

From Federalist Paper #22 ( Alexander Hamilton) “Sophistry may reply, that sovereigns are equal, and that a majority of the votes of the States will be a majority of confederated America. But this kind of logical legerdemain will never counteract the plain suggestions of justice and common-sense. It may happen that this majority of States is a small minority of the people of America; and two thirds of the people of America could not long be persuaded, upon the credit of artificial distinctions and syllogistic subtleties, to submit their interests to the management and disposal of one third. The larger States would after a while revolt from the idea of receiving the law from the smaller.” Hamilton Flays the Filibuster (and Slams the Senate)

Heather Cox Richardson (effect of the filibuster): "Since the Republican Senate seats skew heavily toward rural areas, in this case, it is possible for 41 Republican senators, who represent just 21% of the population, to stop voting rights legislation backed by 70% of Americans."

Randy Petty, Bellingham

About Letter Writer

Citizen Journalist • Member since Oct 12, 2020

We accept letters to the editor from our readers. View policies under "About" on the menu

To comment, Log In or Register

Letter:  U.S. Senate

By Letter WriterOn Oct 23, 2021

Randy Petty on the dysfunctional structure of the U.S. Senate.

Letter: Trust Russ

By Letter WriterOn Oct 19, 2021

Long-time Bellingham City Council member, Gene Knutson, throws his support to Russ Whidbee for the City Council At-Large position

Support for Russ Whidbee for City Council

By Letter WriterOn Oct 18, 2021

Former At-Large Bellingham City Council member, Louise Bjornson, writes in support of Russ Whidbee, for the City Council At-Large seat.

Letter:  Vote for Russ Whidbee

By Letter WriterOn Oct 12, 2021

Ginger Decker writes in support of Russ Whidbee for Bellingham City Council.

Letter: Eddy Ury Support

By Letter WriterOn Oct 07, 2021

Judith Akins writes about her choice for Whatcom County Council.

Letter:  Petition to Ban Teaching Critical Race Theory

By Letter WriterOn Jul 04, 2021

Riley and Bryna Sweeney write about the petition to ban the teaching of Critical Race Theory in the Meridian School District.

Letter: Municipal Court Controversy

By Letter WriterOn Jun 24, 2021

Mary Kay Becker writes about the Bellingham Municipal Court Controversy

Letter: Secretary of Department of Corrections

By Letter WriterOn Feb 20, 2021

Irene Morgan writes a public letter to Governor Inslee about a new director of prisons

Letter: Internet home service and Olympia lawmakers

By Letter WriterOn Feb 01, 2021

Brian Martel on the issue of Internet broadband service to our homes and pending bills in Olympia.

Letter: Bellingham Sweep of Homeless Camp

By Letter WriterOn Jan 30, 2021

Marii Herlinger writes on this past Thursday’s clearing of the homeless camp by city hall.

Letter: Culture Wars

By Letter WriterOn Jan 10, 2021

Mark Ashworth writes about Trump and our current national situation.

Letter: Supporting Ferndale School Levy

By Letter WriterOn Oct 13, 2020

Satpal Sidhu supports Ferndale School Levy

Letter: Christine Grant for PUD Commissioner

By Letter WriterOn Oct 12, 2020

Daniel Kirkpatrick has a letter to the editor endorsing Christine Grant for Public Utility District Commissioner.