About Eric Hirst

Eric Hirst has a Ph.D. in engineering from Stanford University, spent 30 years as an energy policy analyst at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, and retired to Bellingham 18 years ago. He is a local environmental activist.

By: Eric Hirst (17)

Would Adjudication Resolve Nooksack River Water Issues?

By On

How can we best resolve long-standing water-resource issues in the Nooksack River Basin? These problems–primarily too little water in the river and streams during the summer months–have been recognized for at least two decades. Several local entities, both government and nongovernment, have developed plans and conducted projects during this time. Nevertheless, the problems are not resolved. Indeed, primarily because of climate change, these problems are getting worse and will almost surely continue to worsen during the rest of this century.

After completion of an adjudication of surface-water rights in the Yakima Basin, the Washington State Dept. of Ecology (Ecology) proposed to begin adjudication in another basin. Ecology is considering the Nooksack River as a potential site for such a process, with a report on its recommendations due to the legislature in September 2020.

Locally, opinions are divided over the best way to resolve these issues. The Nooksack Indian Tribe and Lummi Nation, which hold the most senior, but un-quantified water rights in the basin, both support adjudication. Local farmers, represented by the Agricultural Water Board (AWB), and the City of Bellingham oppose adjudication.

My sense, based on five years of observation and participation in local water-supply processes, is that adjudication may be the only viable path to increasing flows in the three forks, tributaries, and main-stem Nooksack River. Adjudication is complicated, expensive, and takes years to reach resolution. But I see no other way to encourage/motivate/pressure/compel the key parties to the negotiating table. (To me, the key parties are the two tribes, the farmers, and Ecology.) As Ecology notes, “Adjudications can encourage settlement and partnerships because all water users are joined together in a uniform process.” Also, the end result of adjudication is certainty on who has water rights, in lieu of the current situation in which many water rights are ambiguous. To be clear, I hope the potential of adjudication preempts completion of, and obviates the need for, that process by producing a negotiated settlement.

The purpose of adjudication is to inventory and clarify water rights in order to eliminate ambiguity and uncertainty about these rights. At the end of the process every water user knows how much water he/she/it can use, for what purpose(s), when and where. By itself, adjudication does not put more water in streams and rivers. However, the process would likely extinguish some water rights and eliminate some existing water uses, which would increase stream flows. In particular, the Tribes’ senior water rights to in-stream flows might require reductions in the rights of other out-of-stream water users. But the certainty about one’s water rights following adjudication would allow water users to negotiate with greater confidence than they now have.

To quote Winston Churchill, “Democracy is the worst form of government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time….” In the same manner, adjudication may be the worst way to resolve local water-resource issues, except for all the other approaches that have not yet worked.

For an overview of the situation, and to examine my assessment, please review the full document.

Attached Files

About Eric Hirst

Citizen Journalist • Member since Jul 23, 2015

Eric Hirst has a Ph.D. in engineering from Stanford University, spent 30 years as an energy policy analyst at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, and retired to Bellingham 18 years ago. He [...]

To comment, Log In or Register

Would Adjudication Resolve Nooksack River Water Issues?

By Eric HirstOn May 19, 2020

How can we best resolve long-standing water-resource issues in the Nooksack River Basin? These problems–primarily too little water in the river and streams during the summer months–have been [...]

Water Resource Planning: Prepare - Or Take Our Chances?

By Eric HirstOn Feb 06, 2020

Electricity and water are essential resources in our society. But the way we efficiently plan for our electricity needs is vastly different from how poorly we plan for our water [...]

1 comment, most recent 5 months ago

An Engineer Looks at Washington State Water Law

By Eric HirstOn May 25, 2018

State water law is a complicated mess, a piece-by-piece accumulation and accretion of disparate laws since 1917. Worse, these laws confound solutions to the problems we face today in managing an [...]

5 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Water, Water Everywhere, But ...

By Eric HirstOn Jan 29, 2018

Although we get lots of rain and snow in the winter, Whatcom County faces serious water-supply issues during the summer months. Here are the key issues I see and what [...]

6 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Once Again, Short-Term Interests Beat Long-Term Solutions

By Eric HirstOn Jan 22, 2018

It’s okay to make a mess now because we’ll plan to clean it up later. That, in essence, is what the Washington State Legislature passed and Governor Inslee [...]

Whatcom Water Resources: A Major Problem and a Reasonable Solution

By Eric HirstOn Dec 18, 2017

Streamflows in the Nooksack River and its tributaries are very low almost every summer. These low flows hurt salmon, trout, and other fish because they contribute to high water temperatures, [...]

10 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Most Cost-Effective Way to Save Water for Homes

By Eric HirstOn Jul 31, 2017

When asked why he robbed banks, Willie Sutton supposedly said “because that’s where the money is.” In the same vein, programs intended to save water should focus on those [...]

7 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Water for Whatcom Irrigation

By Eric HirstOn May 02, 2017

Whatcom County farmers use a lot of water every summer to irrigate their pastures and berry fields. But the public never knows just how much water irrigation uses. This means [...]

10 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Myths About Rural Residential Wells

By Eric HirstOn Mar 27, 2017

The Washington Supreme Court issued its decision on rural residential wells in October 2016. Since then, there has been a glut of misinformation about what the court said and how Whatcom [...]

5 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Future Prospects for Whatcom County Water Supply

By Eric HirstOn Feb 11, 2017

Farmers need water for crops and cattle. City-dwellers want water for yards, gardens and kiddie pools. Salmon need streams with enough cold, clear water to enable them to spawn and [...]

2 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Whatcom County Water Use: When and Why

By Eric HirstOn Jan 07, 2017

Eric Hirst contributes this brief overview of a complex water situation. These views are supported by the attached well researched report by Hirst. During the winter, it’s hard to [...]

7 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Interim Ordinance on Rural Water Wells is Essential

By Eric HirstOn Dec 03, 2016

Eric Hirst guest writes. We appreciate his expert perspective on this important local issue. Elisabeth Britt, in a NW Citizen article on Nov 25, argues that Whatcom County made a mistake [...]

3 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Whatcom Farmers and Eric Hirst Dialog

By Eric HirstOn Dec 19, 2015

Eric Hirst guest writes again on water issues in Whatcom County. Publisher note: We all use water every single day at home and in commerce and industry. By far, the [...]

1 comment, most recent 4 years ago

Whatcom Co.: 90 Million Gallons of Water a Day

By Eric HirstOn Jul 22, 2015

Guest writer Eric Hirst is retired to Bellingham and enjoys using his professional abilities to benefit our community. He has a doctorate from Stanford and spent his professional career doing [...]

10 comments, most recent 4 years ago

Eric Hirst Resigns Greenways Committee

By Eric HirstOn Nov 09, 2010

Editor note: Of course this posting is with Eric’s permission. Our website is not able to exactly reproduce the formatting and bullet points in his letter. Thus there is [...]

1 comment, most recent 9 years ago

Thriving Beyond Sustainability - a book review

By Eric HirstOn Sep 07, 2010

Book review by guest writer, Eric Hirst of Bellingham Thriving Beyond Sustainability: Pathways to a Resilient Society by Andres R. Edwards, New Society Publishers, Gabriola Island, BC, Canada, 2010. I can’[...]

Book Review:  Whole Earth Discipline

By Eric HirstOn Jul 16, 2010

Eric Hirst is guest writer. Environmental Heretic or Prophet? A Review of Stewart Brand’s Whole Earth Discipline: An Ecopragmatist Manifesto, Viking Press, 2009. Stewart Brand’s new book shakes the [...]

1 comment, most recent 9 years ago