About Ralph Schwartz

After 13 years in mainstream journalism, Ralph Schwartz left The Bellingham Herald in November 2015. He's now a freelance editor and writer looking for a regular paycheck.

By: Ralph Schwartz (39)

After worker victories, The Bellingham Herald’s union is in place


McClatchy put up a fight, but newsroom employees at The Bellingham Herald and three other Washington newspapers got what they wanted -- a single union to represent workers at all four papers. The new bargaining unit, the Washington State NewsGuild, is preparing to sit down with corporate representatives in the weeks or months ahead, to negotiate what it hopes will be more stability for both employees and the communities they serve. 

After guild members from the Herald, The News Tribune of Tacoma, The Olympian and the Tri-City Herald signaled their intent to unionize under a single banner, McClatchy objected. The newspaper chain argued in a Dec. 31 petition to the National Labor Relations Board that employees at each of the four newspapers should have their own unions, advocating for their unique interests. The guild saw McClatchy’s move to break up the union as a “blatant attempt to undercut our power,” as Tacoma reporter Chase Hutchinson described it before the NLRB heard the case in January. (Workers had reason to be wary. McClatchy's largest creditor, Chatham Asset Management, took over the chain last year after it declared bankruptcy. Chatham isn't always interested in preserving the newspapers it owns, as Canada's largest newspaper chain learned.)

The NLRB sided with the guild in a ruling announced Feb. 24. One day later, McClatchy said it would recognize the guild, eliminating the need for a union vote among workers that had been tentatively scheduled for early March.

So far, all the pieces are in place for McClatchy management and employees to figure out how to make everyone happy -- give the journalists fair compensation, give corporate something it is willing to sustain, and, importantly, give four Washington state communities the news they need in the long term.

Responding to an inquiry from NWCitizen, McClatchy Communications Director Jeanne Segal provided the following statement on March 1: “We will voluntarily recognize the bargaining unit our newsroom colleagues in Washington state seek to form. This pathway allows us to accelerate the process of starting negotiations. We look forward to working collaboratively with the Washington State NewsGuild to advance this process and ensure a strong future for local journalism in Tacoma, Olympia, Bellingham and Tri-Cities.” 

Segal also pointed to a statement posted to Twitter on Feb. 25 by Stephanie Pedersen, McClatchy’s northwest regional editor: “Last week I told our team I’m eager to get to the negotiating table. This week’s news makes it clear one guild in Washington covering four newsrooms is how that will happen. We’re ready to move forward, voluntarily recognize and quickly work towards a contract.” Pedersen added, “The leadership team and our colleagues fundamentally share the same mission: to produce strong local journalism that serves our communities.”

Denver Pratt, a Bellingham Herald reporter who has spearheaded the union effort locally, said both the NLRB ruling and McClatchy’s subsequent decision to recognize the union were “great news” but were only the beginning.

“It just means we can start getting to the big issues,” Pratt said in a phone interview March 1. “We can start working to make sure we have robust local journalism in our communities for decades to come.” The guild will select a bargaining committee from among its members and finalize a list of negotiating points. That list is sure to include fair pay and steps toward more newsroom diversity, to ensure that the communities’ news is presented by people who better reflect the makeup of those communities. The status of Bellingham breaking news reporter Dave Rasbach may also be decided in negotiations, Pratt said. McClatchy is contesting his membership in the union, citing his occasional duties as editor.

One of the most pressing concerns at the guild currently is a minimum wage McClatchy promised in a company-wide email on Feb. 5, only to say later that Washington journalists wouldn’t be getting the wage guarantee, scheduled to take effect March 1.

“McClatchy has announced its intent to withhold those raises from Washington journalists, claiming our ongoing union drive prevents the company from providing this money,” the guild said in a Feb. 19 press release. McClatchy’s Segal declined to comment on the raise issue.

McClatchy’s new minimum wage would be $20.19 or $21.63, depending on the community. Pratt wasn’t sure which figure applied in Bellingham, but in either case the new minimum wage would mean raises for two Bellingham Herald employees and nine McClatchy journalists statewide, she said.

“We believe that our employees in Washington are eligible for those, and we’re working on making that happen,” Pratt said.

While Pratt characterized last week’s developments as “a huge, exciting moment,” and she said she was pleased that McClatchy “sent us the signal that they are ready to move forward,” guild members are casting a wary eye toward Florida. One Herald Guild, representing employees at el Nuevo Herald and the Miami Herald, took to Twitter on Feb. 25 to vent frustration over negotiations with McClatchy that had begun more than a year earlier. “(McClatchy) claims staff are partners in local journalism, while making anti-worker proposals that would allow it to layoff journalists at will, outsource Herald journalism, & fire journalists for making social media statements that are work-related or critical of the company,” One Herald Guild tweeted, adding, “After 1yr of bargaining, we demand that McClatchy negotiate in good faith to address our proposals for wages, benefits & policies to build up our newsroom. Respond to our proposals at the table. Stop making proposals to weaken the newsroom. Pick up the pace of negotiations.”

Let’s hope that a year from now, The Bellingham Herald’s workers have a contract and a newfound sense of security, not the litany of complaints coming out of Miami today.

About Ralph Schwartz

Posting Citizen Journalist • Member since May 23, 2014

After 13 years in mainstream journalism, Ralph Schwartz left The Bellingham Herald in November 2015. He's now a freelance editor and writer looking for a regular paycheck.

Dick Conoboy

Mar 02, 2021


Good news as far as the union is concerned, however, those “new” minimum wages are really still grossly inadequate.  The fact that the new minimum means a RAISE for two employees, is mindboggling.  About 5 years ago I wrote a piece about debt peonage and the minimum wage entitled $15 Minimum Wage - Assured Debt Peonage.  I said then:

“All of this folderol around $15, as if it were to save the American worker from poverty (it won’t), is all the more ridiculous in that to actually arrive at a living wage, at this very moment a worker should be getting $20-25 per hour.  My article from August 2015 entitled $15/hr Minimum Wage - Seriously? revealed the nasty secret about the $15 minimum wage bandwagon: it has no wheels.  Unfortunately, the hoopla has everyone fixed on this magical dollar amount instead of what it really takes to make a living.  Naysayers also warn of job loss if even $15 is enacted across the country.  In an article in the Washington Post we hear this,  “‘What should be the criterion about setting a minimum wage?” he [Mark Levinson, the chief economist for the Service Employees International Union] asked. ‘Should it be the level which produces minimal job loss? Or should it be, in the language of the Fair Labor Standards Act, the maintenance of the minimum standard of living necessary for the health, efficiency, and general well-being of workers?’” 

Five years and we now consider what might have been adequate but not available then, is minimally adequate now.  That’s progress for you.


Jeffrey Bodé

Mar 05, 2021

I agree with Dick. So does Jon Schwarz at The Intercept.  https://theintercept.com/2021/03/05/minimum-wage-raise-15/


Dick Conoboy

Mar 05, 2021


From the Intercept article:

“Indeed, since 1950, the hourly minimum wage has almost never been lower than it is now. Of course, 1950 is literally a lifetime ago, and the U.S. is now a completely different country. Our per capita gross domestic product is now four times greater. A UNIVAC computer of the time was 38 feet long, weighed eight tons, and had about 1/1,000,000 of the memory of today’s cheapest iPhone.”

The GDP as a measure of growth is a fallacy.  The GDP counts as productivity earning gains achieved in the FIRE sector, that is finance, insurance and real estate.  I am surprised the Intercept did not weed out this falsity.

Michael Hudson writes in an article on The rentier resurgence and takeover: Finance Capitalism vs. Industrial Capitalism:  “The transformation of academic economic theory under today’s finance capitalism has reversed the progressive and indeed radical thrust of the classical political economy that evolved into Marxism. Post-classical theory depicts the financial and other rentier sectors as an intrinsic part of the industrial economy. Today’s national income and GDP accounting formats are compiled in keeping with this anti-classical reaction depicting the FIRE sector and its allied rent-seeking sectors as an addition to national income, not a subtrahend. Interest, rents and monopoly prices all are counted as “earnings” – as if all income is earned as intrinsic parts of industrial capitalism, not predatory extraction as overhead property and financial claims.” 



To comment, Log In or Register

After worker victories, The Bellingham Herald’s union is in place

By Ralph SchwartzOn Mar 02, 2021

McClatchy put up a fight, but newsroom employees at The Bellingham Herald and three other Washington newspapers got what they wanted -- a single union to represent workers at all [...]

3 comments, most recent 4 months ago

McClatchy seeks to break up union that includes Bellingham Herald staff

By Ralph SchwartzOn Jan 11, 2021

McClatchy, the corporate owners of The Bellingham Herald who were taken over by a hedge fund after bankruptcy, appears willing to accept the inevitable. News employees at the chain’s [...]

5 comments, most recent 6 months ago

‘Now we will have a voice’—Bellingham Herald’s newsroom joins union

By Ralph SchwartzOn Dec 22, 2020

There’s no telling how far a newspaper will fall. When I started as a reporter at The Bellingham Herald in 2011, some 25 people were working in the newsroom, including six [...]

2 comments, most recent 6 months ago

Portland protest: confessions of a riot tourist

By Ralph SchwartzOn Aug 03, 2020

I decided to make the 260-mile trip down Interstate 5 from Bellingham to Portland, to attend a nightly protest that had attracted national attention. As I prepared by packing dark, nondescript [...]

4 comments, most recent 11 months ago

Anacortes Council member Lovelett to replace Ranker in state Senate

By Ralph SchwartzOn Feb 05, 2019

Anacortes City Council member Liz Lovelett was sworn in late Tuesday, Feb. 5, as Washington state’s newest senator, to represent the 40th Legislative District. Members of the San Juan and [...]

2 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Two dozen want Murphy’s Bellingham council seat

By Ralph SchwartzOn Sep 26, 2018

Democracy is not a spectator sport. Jean Layton told me this last year when I asked her why she chose to challenge Roxanne Murphy, who was seeking reelection to the [...]

18 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Tough choice for Democrats: Who will challenge Ericksen?

By Ralph SchwartzOn May 01, 2018

Democrats think they can do it. If only they can motivate voters to turn in their ballots in numbers comparable to a presidential election year, then Democrats say they can [...]

7 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Ericksen a tough out for Democrats in 2018

By Ralph SchwartzOn Apr 17, 2018

UPDATE: The campaign treasurer for Tim Ballew II, who is running as a Democrat against Doug Ericksen for his state Senate seat in the 42nd Legislative District, turned in two [...]

2 comments, most recent 3 years ago

One year in, Trump’s biggest Wash. donor has no buyer’s remorse

By Ralph SchwartzOn Jan 21, 2018

I was reminded recently of Peter Gigante, the Fairhaven resident who has the distinction of being Washington state’s single largest donor to the 2016 Donald Trump presidential campaign. I interviewed [...]

2 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Count ‘em: 29 people seek vacancy on Whatcom County Council

By Ralph SchwartzOn Dec 20, 2017

I feel I need to walk back the statement in my last article about the importance of participating in democracy by stepping up to take public office. The Whatcom County [...]

1 comment, most recent 3 years ago

Crowded field: 11 seek Whatcom council vacancy days before deadline

By Ralph SchwartzOn Dec 16, 2017

One necessary condition for a healthy democracy is citizens’ willingness to participate—not just by casting votes but by stepping up to represent their peers by taking government offices. I [...]

4 comments, most recent 3 years ago

District-only dead? Whatcom council to weigh return to countywide vote

By Ralph SchwartzOn Nov 20, 2017

Update by publisher: Wed, Nov 22. At last night’s county council meeting, the two proposed ordinances were not brought forward. They were not voted on. Apparently they were discussed in [...]

2 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Election recap: Conservatives start to make inroads on Whatcom Council

By Ralph SchwartzOn Nov 13, 2017

​No matter how you slice it, district-only voting is a good thing if you’re a conservative in Whatcom County. Right-wing politicos on the 2015 county Charter Review Commission managed to [...]

Conservative Whatcom candidates distance themselves from GOP

By Ralph SchwartzOn Aug 21, 2017

​Four conservative candidates for elected office in Whatcom County have gotten together to chart a third way through local politics—one that doesn’t involve Republicans or Democrats. The four—[...]

1 comment, most recent 3 years ago

If Donovan defeats Glasser in county race, can she take his old seat?

By Ralph SchwartzOn Aug 11, 2017

Whatcom County government is in the midst of what can be a confusing transition, as the seven seats for County Council leave behind the old three-district system and begin to [...]

5 comments, most recent 3 years ago

‘Upstream’ book review: any hope for salmon?

By Ralph SchwartzOn Jul 20, 2017

​If you’re reading this article, chances are “Upstream: Searching for Wild Salmon, from River to Table” by Langdon Cook (Ballantine, $27) won’t teach you too much you don’t [...]

1 comment, most recent 4 years ago

Primary: I’m voting Jean Layton for city council—and you should, too

By Ralph SchwartzOn Jul 09, 2017

​Before Democrats in the Whatcom establishment raise an objection, let me say up front this is not an endorsement for the general election. This is not an endorsement of any [...]

4 comments, most recent 4 years ago

Democrat infighting emerges in Bellingham’s at-large race

By Ralph SchwartzOn May 14, 2017

​Democrats are in a major fight in the wake of Donald Trump’s victory in the 2016 presidential election. Sure, they are throwing everything they can at the new White House, [...]

2 comments, most recent 4 years ago

100 days: Largest Wash. Trump donor, from Fairhaven, likes what he sees

By Ralph SchwartzOn May 03, 2017

​Not one to shy away from a media cliche, I followed up with Peter Gigante on the occasion of Donald Trump’s 100th day in the White House. OK, so [...]

11 comments, most recent 3 years ago

What did Ericksen know? Trump protesters facing trial seek subpoena

By Ralph SchwartzOn Apr 04, 2017

The “Whatcom Three,” who last May blocked Guide Meridian Road in Lynden on the day President Donald Trump made a campaign appearance there, want to know whether Republican state Senator [...]

1 comment, most recent 4 years ago