Recent Articles

Emergency Management

Garrett O’Brien guest writes about how Bellingham can learn from successful programs for the homeless elsewhere and would do well to abandon ineffectual approaches.

Garrett O’Brien guest writes about how Bellingham can learn from successful programs for the homeless elsewhere and would do well to abandon ineffectual approaches.

By

[Guest Writer Garrett O’Brien is a lifelong resident of Bellingham and lives with his wife Brittany and their three children in the Birchwood neighborhood. Garrett has worked in the building trades since 1995, has a degree in construction management, and is the president of Volonta Corporation.] 

Alarmist language and accompanying emergency declarations often shape public policy, but not successful public policy. Tax dollars flow from the emergency-induced public policy to the balance sheets of its most strident advocates. Once funded, such advocates are free to implement programs that support their social vision, but are rarely held accountable to performance measured against clearly stated goals. 

A regional example of this phenomenon occurred in 2015, when then-mayor of Seattle, Ed Murray, declared a state of emergency, which he asserted was necessary to address the "devastating" homelessness crisis. Supported by the myriad homeless service providers set to receive the additional emergency funding, Murray confidently told the Seattle Times that Seattle "will have more administrative authority and flexibility in contracting for services and distributing resources." 

The prevailing narrative of an emergency homelessness crisis was so widely accepted that the city and Seattle Times gave little attention to the Annual Homeless Assessment Report (AHAR) published that same year by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). In contradiction to the declarations of elected officials, the report showed that homelessness in Washington state had been steadily decreasing over the previous eight-year period, belying the claim of an emergency crisis. Even less attention was afforded to the same AHAR report published in 2019 that measured the change in homelessness for the five years after the state of emergency declaration, showing that homelessness increased by 11% despite the additional funding. 

Mayor Murray was correct that the emergency declaration would authorize dramatic spending increases for homeless services. Still, there is little evidence to suggest the increased spending has been effective in reducing homelessness. The lesson: Declarations of a crisis should be supported by evidence, and proposed solutions, once implemented, should be measured for efficacy.  

Within most statistics, data can be mined to support almost any narrative or overall vision; in recognizing this axiom, it is vital to pursue evidence-based practices with clearly stated goals, routinely and objectively measured. In short, are our efforts working? 

Far from being an expert in the field of social services, I rely on, and am grateful to, the many service providers who apply their talents toward reducing homelessness and artfully navigating the immense web of funding and regulatory constraints that further complicate their job. The causes and classifications of people experiencing homelessness are nuanced, and services for veterans, families, and those struggling with drug addiction or mental health care must differ — and simply sheltering people is not an end in itself. 

Pursuing solutions to complex issues requires a plan, a commitment to the plan, and a willingness to abandon approaches that prove ineffectual. Ad hoc responses induced by inclement weather should not be accepted as a substitute for a coherent year-round strategy. We need a central command approach that provides an overarching structure to link the many disparate service providers currently serving their niche demographic.

Fortunately, small cities like Bellingham don't need to create this structure alone, and we can learn from the successful programs of others. For example, the city of San Diego, in partnership with Jewish Family Service, operates safe parking lots for people who are recently, and often for the first time, experiencing homelessness. The lots are safe, secure, and adequately staffed, allowing caseworkers to develop individual relationships and direct people toward appropriate resources. The backdrop to the program's success is a secure environment with enforced rules that prohibit drugs and alcohol, require visitor registration, and holds residents accountable to work toward securing permanent housing. 

Community Solutions is another example of a nonprofit that provides a successful blueprint to cities serious about reducing homelessness. Community Solutions provides an overarching structure that partnering cities can use as an overlay to help coordinate their existing services. Cities can use this blueprint to improve their established and diverse social service infrastructure by providing a central command and common goals. I have had the opportunity to visit a Community Solutions partner city and observe firsthand how small changes, like replacing the "point-in-time" count with an individualized "by name" count, can humanize and personalize the outreach team's efforts. 

These are just two programs I believe are worth further research and consideration as Bellingham works toward a sensible and long-term approach to reducing homelessness. As our elected officials work toward pragmatic solutions, I hope they resist alarmist rhetoric that is seldom an antecedent of successful outcomes, and are willing to challenge prevailing social narratives in pursuit of measurable success. 

Comments by Readers

Karen Steen

Feb 28, 2021

Thank you, Mr. O’Brien, for this timely reality check and solutions-based approach to Bellingham’s housing crisis. Consider also Los Angeles’ black hole of public funding for emergency housing. As with Seattle, I expect inadequate and failed programs are occurring in most west coast cities attempting to manage a national housing and mental health crisis at the local level.

Your suggestions for comprehensive, evidence-based criteria for program development and funding, together with the systemic assessments and recommendations in “The Gristle” and “Beyond Camp 210” (2/3 Cascadia Weekly), offer solutions worthy of public investment and implementation.

I hope City Hall and Bellingham citizens can emerge from the fog of a frontal assault these recent months; consider anew the public safety and fiscal responsibilities of Bellingham; and embrace solutions suggested by you, “The Gristle” and “Beyond Camp 210” (2/3 Cascadia Weekly).

Read More...

Christopher S Hudson

Mar 02, 2021

Good article, thank you. Emotional responses to perceived or actual emergencies derail critical analysis, reasoned response and assessment of actions.

Los Angeles is a classic example of throwing money at an inadequately understood social problem and hoping for the best. There is no one I encounter in Bellingham who is not concerned with our complex local homeless situation, which is part of a greater regional situation and part of a national situation. And no one has “the answer.”

I think we need a thorough census of local groups, to determine the details of that population. “The genius of the Founders was taking a tool of government and making it a tool of political empowerment for the governed over their government.” (from Census in the Constitution). Self-empowerment!

How many are homeless in greater Bellingham?

....because of financial hardship?

.... or a drug/booze lifestyle choice?

....or untreated mental illness?

....or many other reasons?

I have no idea.

Read More...

Garrett O’Brien

Mar 02, 2021

Thank you for your comment Christopher. 

Read More...

Michael Lilliquist

Mar 07, 2021

Garrett,

You bring up Safe Parking as one proven response.  Indeed, such programs have been successful elsewhere, including in nearby Kirkland, WA.  Unfortunetly there does nto appear to be local support for such a program, even when the City fo Bellingham offerred to help set up and pay for opertion of a Safe Parking program.  Last year, the City published an offer of funding, and reached out to local organizations to see who might be interested. In the end, no one replied that theyt were interetested. maybe it was Covid, maybe it was concern about volunteer burnout, maybe it was some other reason.  I don;t know. We tried.

If you know anyone who in interetested in giving it a “go,” I can try once again to set up a funding offer from the City.  Or, people can do it on their own as a private charity. Wjatever works best.

Read More...

Garrett O’Brien

Mar 09, 2021

Thank you for this information Michael, and your continuing work on these issues. It may take sustained effort, addtional funding, and increased outreach to overcome the current inertia.  

Read More...

Emergency Management

By Guest WriterOn Feb 27, 2021

Garrett O’Brien guest writes about how Bellingham can learn from successful programs for the homeless elsewhere and would do well to abandon ineffectual approaches.

5 comments, most recent 6 months ago

The Reality Of Zoom And Citizen Participation

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 21, 2021

City council and planning commission meetings were poor arrangements to begin with, and with Zoom it is very much worse.

4 comments, most recent 4 months ago

Letter: Secretary of Department of Corrections

By Letter WriterOn Feb 20, 2021

Irene Morgan writes a public letter to Governor Inslee about a new director of prisons

Public Banking For The State of Washington Inching Along

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 13, 2021

A substitute bill for the original SB 5188 was accepted and moved to the Ways and Means Committee for further consideration.

2 comments, most recent 7 months ago

Ranked-Choice Voting – Let’s Keep It Moving

By Stoney BirdOn Feb 12, 2021

Current legislation, moving forward in Olympia, would permit localities to adopt ranked-choice voting as an upgrade to their currently mandated top-two system.

1 comment, most recent 7 months ago

Cruising And Tourism: Wretched Excess

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 10, 2021

The monumental, pre-COVID levels of cruise ships and world tourism were not sustainable.

4 comments, most recent 7 months ago

Political Pretzel Logic without Cognitive Dissonance

By Guest WriterOn Feb 09, 2021

Ray Kamada guest writes on how to have your cake and eat it too.

5 comments, most recent 7 months ago

COB Puts The BAG In A Box

By Jon HumphreyOn Feb 07, 2021

The city has instituted unnecessary restrictions on the Broadband Advisory Group’s discussion and outside input.

3 comments, most recent 7 months ago

Letter: Internet home service and Olympia lawmakers

By Letter WriterOn Feb 01, 2021

Brian Martel on the issue of Internet broadband service to our homes and pending bills in Olympia.

Task Force Slams Bellingham City Hall

By John ServaisOn Jan 31, 2021

The Whatcom Human Rights Task Force has sent an open letter to the Community regarding the sweep of Camp 210.

Letter: Bellingham Sweep of Homeless Camp

By Letter WriterOn Jan 30, 2021

Marii Herlinger writes on this past Thursday’s clearing of the homeless camp by city hall.

Public Banking Bill Gets A Warmer Reception In Olympia

By Dick ConoboyOn Jan 30, 2021

For the first time in a decade a hearing on a public banking bill found more supporters than detractors.

City Hall homeless camp cleared out a day early

By John ServaisOn Jan 28, 2021

Bellingham started clearing 24 hours earlier than announced days ago. Antifa has showed up in numbers to provoke. Heavy police presence

2 comments, most recent 7 months ago

State’s Telecom Standards Full of Loopholes

By Jon HumphreyOn Jan 27, 2021

Regulatory standards in SB-5511 offer nothing but give the appearance of doing something.

Planned Roberts Bank Terminal Threatens Orcas

By Michael RiordanOn Jan 26, 2021

New Roberts Bank container-ship terminal proposed by the Port of Vancouver would generate additional vessel traffic that will impact endangered Southern Resident Killer Whales.

3 comments, most recent 5 months ago

City Hall Clutches its Pearls

By John ServaisOn Jan 26, 2021

Mayor Fleetwood and outgoing council members could not handle the truth at last night’s Bellingham City Council meeting. Homeless people and their advocates spoke truth to power.

25 comments, most recent 7 months ago

Will City Double-Down to Kill Public Trail?

By Tip JohnsonOn Jan 24, 2021

Tip Johnson makes the case that the City’s cozy relations with developers and its neighborhoods-be-damned attitude is costing us all.

3 comments, most recent 7 months ago

New Public Banking Bill Introduced in Olympia - Hearing On January 28th

By Dick ConoboyOn Jan 21, 2021

A public bank in Washington is sorely needed for infrastructure projects and more especially with COVID-19 and the resultant severe economic downturn.

5 comments, most recent 7 months ago

Satpal on Insurrection

By Guest WriterOn Jan 14, 2021

Satpal Sidhu, our Whatcom County Executive, writes us a statement in response to attack on Capitol

2 comments, most recent 8 months ago

Gene Knutson to Retire from Bellingham Council

By John ServaisOn Jan 12, 2021

Gene Knutson today announced he will not run for reelection this year and is retiring from the Bellingham City Council.

8 comments, most recent 2 months ago