Recent Articles

Mayor Is Asked To Preserve Trail


Update Thur, May 6:  There were administrative mistakes at city hall that prevented the mayor from phoning Daniel back.  Today Seth phoned Daniel.  


This letter is posted with permission from Daniel Kirkpatrick.  The mayor emailed back to Daniel on the 28th, “I would enjoy talking to you in person.”  Since then, the mayor has not taken Daniel's calls nor called back.  - John Servais

Seth Fleetwood, Mayor, City of Bellingham

28 April 2021

Dear Seth:

On Monday, April 26th, the Bellingham City Council approved a developer’s application to vacate the Douglas Avenue Right of Way (ROW) in order to add additional units to his project. I urge you to veto this street vacation.

In 1993 I worked with many of my neighbors in Happy Valley to build a trail on the Douglas Avenue ROW between 20th and 21st Streets.  This was a “Make a Difference Day” project and was sanctioned by the City Parks Department.  We had watched as numerous street ROWs were vacated in our area, resulting in increased density and reduced open space while enriching developers.  Our goal was to use the ROW for its intended purpose:  To make it easier for people to get around.  A secondary goal was to preserve open space and limit density in one of the densest parts of the City.

In the summer of 2020 a developer approached the City seeking to vacate the very ROW upon which we had built our trail, by now in continuous use for a full generation.  The application should have been denied outright:  City ordinances prohibit the vacation of ROWs that are already in use for public transportation purposes.  The City Hearing Examiner – for reasons I cannot fathom – accepted the developer’s premise that the ROW was not in use, without apparent due diligence.  After all, the City’s own trail map has shown our Douglas Avenue trail since at least 1996 – see the circled area on the attached scan.  Nonetheless the Hearing Examiner approved the vacation request.

Last December, when word got out about the Hearing Examiner’s ill-advised recommendation, the City Council was deluged with input from neighbors decrying this vacation request.  The City Council consequently punted the matter back to the Hearing Examiner.  Upon a second review, the Hearing Examiner made no recommendation on the vacation request, again for reasons I cannot fathom.  It was particularly striking for her to comment that, while some of the City’s requirements on vacating streets were not met, others were – as if the laws on the books were to be applied only as advantageous to a predetermined outcome.

Well, this week the City Council – again to the great dismay of myself and others in Happy Valley – approved the ROW vacation request.  It is alarming to get the sense that the City of Bellingham is disregarding citizens’ concerns, while also treating its own statutes as relative.  

You alone can correct this disturbing situation via a mayoral veto.  I ask that you review this case and take courageous action.  It’s not just Happy Valley residents who are watching.  Anyone who has worked to improve their neighborhood, on their own time and with limited City support, has a stake in seeing the City of Bellingham stand in support of its citizens – especially when a developer wants to maximize profit at the expense of the public good.

On behalf of those of us in Happy Valley and throughout the City, please veto the Douglas Avenue ROW vacation.   Thank you.

Daniel Kirkpatrick, 1132 19th Street, Bellingham WA 98225

Comments by Readers

Tip Johnson

Apr 30, 2021

It will be unfortunate to have to go through this exercise again. When city staff colluded to vacate right-of-ways around Hoag’s Pond to benefit a retiring public works administrator, citizens mounted a referendum to overturn the decision. Mere notice of the referendum caused then Mayor Asmundson to take a closer look. He then vetoed the measure. The council overruled the veto, but when the referendum was easily qualified, voted to rescind rather than suffer the embarrassment of a public campaign.

This case features a disturbingly cozy relationship between Planning staff and a land use consultant and member, until only recently Chair, of the Planning Commission.  It doesn’t meet the City’s own policies for vacation and ignores relevant state statutes. The Hearing Examiners findings include conspicuous errors of fact. 

And it importantly tries to establish a precedent for essentially up zoning property without public review. In this case an undevelopable right-of-way, already opened as a public way, could add up to seven units to an already approved ten units. The trail would become private and subject to the whims of the now and future owners. 

Why are private property rights frequently championed by the city , while public property rights receive little attention or support?  If we are to succeed in creating connected, walkable neighborhoods, we will need to challenge and correct this lopsided oversight. 


Jamie K. Donaldson

Apr 30, 2021

P.U.!,” short for Latin puteo “that stinks,” and it certainly does.

Since when does a small progressive city go through the plannning and review process to end up taking away a publicly-created and city-sanctioned trail and greenspace that have been enjoyed for decades?  As Bellingham continues to grow and fill in, we should be creating pocket parks, greenspaces, community gardens and pedestrian byways—not removing them, especially in densifying neighborhoods.  I don’t pretend to understand all the ins and outs of the statues that were invoked by those on both sides of this issue, but I do understand the value of trails and trees.  I use the Douglas trail myself and find the mature trees, bird song, and shade a very welcome respite from the concrete and bustle.  It’s called quality of life.

So our only recourse now is for Mayor Fleetwood to veto the city council’s decision that will effectively take away this public good for a developer’s private gain?  Then, as has been popularly said before, Mayor Fleetwood, please make it so.


Dianne Foster

Apr 30, 2021

Most of us who supported Seth for mayor did so because we thought he would be more helpful in fighting vulture capitalist developers than histrionic April Barker.   So far,  I’m not seeing much difference,  but there is still time.    We raised almost $2000.00 in Sehome and York neighborhoods in 48 hours to stop the teardown of the historic town of New Whatcom by Hammer Properties on Billy Frank Jr. Street,  and appealed to the Mayor,  Council,  and Hearing Examiner to stop this crime by big money.   (These houses on BFJ street were the early homes of prominent Bellingham citizens,  each unique in architecture,  built from old growth timbers now in the landfill).   Nothing came of it of course,  as developers rule.   Once they end single family zoning,  I expect Hammer and Hansen will own everything,  from which they will extract huge profits as absentee landlords,  and we can expect more teardowns for expensive student housing.   On the other hand,  the old Aloha Motel project is truly affordable housing from which there will be neither private extraction or teardowns of beautiful old places.   It is around the corner from my house,  and I welcome these new neighbors.   Some research I did noted that Hammer has several LLC’s,  one of which is “Billy Frank Jr. LLC”(!).   What an egregious twist on the name of this saint who believed in historical preservation; he must be rolling in his grave.



May 01, 2021

Though it was long ago, I still remember Hugh Fleetwood leading the opposition to Syre’s mall project, Bellis Fair, in a protected wetlands.  I hope Seth does too.


Aaron Brand

May 01, 2021

I am in favor of maintaining pedestrian friendly rights-of-way, but it seems to me that we are trying to find solutions to a housing crisis right now. Is there not a way to increase density (which, if I’m not mistaken, improves housing options) while maintaining a trail in this location?


Paul K Schissler

May 01, 2021

That was a surprising vote from the Council; ought to have gone the other way.  I hope Mayor Fleetwood vetoes the Council decision.

Lessons from the Hoag’s Pond episode say gear up for a referendum now.

Lessons from the other end of Happy Valley Neighborhood, at 15th and Harris, say nearby neighbors might be wiling to support of a ROW vacation ONLY IF the requester offers to build high-quality homes that are owner-occupied and permanently affordable for people with incomes less than the median income. The City agreed to vacate 15th between Harris and McKenzie ONLY IF Kulshan Community Land Trust found more community investment to add five more homes so that Matthei Place would have 14 homes on less than one acre. And the City retained perpetual easements for pedestrians, bike, and utilities throught the former ROW. 

Lessons from us over at Fairhaven Neighbors say City Hall will pay more attention when you hire an attorney to raise questions on your behalf. 

And really, does that appraisal of the Douglas ROW pass the smell test? I guess the appraised amount is not an issue for the Hearing Examiner process, but how much does land for that many homes cost, usually?


Hue Beattie

May 02, 2021

The hearing examiner should have her salary examined.  The council has forgotten, and I think Pinky Vargas never knew it; that what’s good for the Neighborhood is good for the city. I watched the deliberations on zoom and would like to commend Councilwoman Lisa Anderson for seeing thru the charade and voting to deny the vacation.


Mayor Is Asked To Preserve Trail

By John ServaisOn Apr 30, 2021

Update Thur, May 6:  There were administrative mistakes at city hall that prevented the mayor from phoning Daniel back.  Today Seth phoned Daniel.  ------This letter is posted with [...]

7 comments, most recent 4 days ago

Affordable Housing Arrives At Bellingham’s Waterfront?

By Dick ConoboyOn Apr 27, 2021

After years of anticipation, Bellingham's prayers have been answered: affordable housing at the Waterfront. Not.I was drawn to the “good news” site by an advertisement in a local newspaper. [...]

10 comments, most recent 6 days ago

Dead Or Alive?  Schrödinger’s Public Banking Bill

By Dick ConoboyOn Apr 18, 2021

Physicist Erwin Schrödinger devised a thought experiment described here:Schrödinger's cat: a cat, a flask of poison, and a radioactive source are placed in a sealed box. If [...]

Boulevard Park And Infrastructure: Another COB Missed Opportunity

By Jon HumphreyOn Apr 05, 2021

[The following article is a modification of a piece by Jon Humphrey that appeared in on March 30, 2021 entitled “Boulevard Park And Infrastructure (131 years and the COB still refuses [...]

4 comments, most recent 1 month ago

State Public Banking (Cooperative) Bill - Update on House Actions

By Dick ConoboyOn Mar 28, 2021

{ Udpate 4/10/2021: E2SSB 5188 the public cooperative (banking bill), now in the Rules Committee, can use a push by a legislator by requesting that it be brought out of Rules and [...]

8 comments, most recent 3 weeks ago

COB: Go Ahead, Discuss All You Want…

By Jon HumphreyOn Mar 23, 2021

3/26/2021 Update: Thanks to public pressure the COB has finally started to post the BAG meeting recordings. While it takes them an uncommonly long time to post the videos, they date [...]

3 comments, most recent 1 month ago

The Battle for Bellingham’s Tiny Homes

By Guest WriterOn Mar 20, 2021

[Douglas Gustafson guest writes. Doug is Chairman of HomesNOW! Not Later, an all-volunteer nonprofit organization operating in Bellingham and Whatcom County. HomesNOW operates Unity Village, the first tiny home community [...]

27 comments, most recent 6 days ago

A Variant Virus Outbreak in Whatcom County?

By Michael RiordanOn Mar 12, 2021

According to recent data from the Washington state Department of Health, a serious outbreak of the B.1.1.7 coronavirus strain occurred in Whatcom County during February, about a month earlier than [...]

10 comments, most recent 1 month ago

State Public Banking (Cooperative) Bill Moves To The House

By Dick ConoboyOn Mar 07, 2021

After a decade long effort on the part of State Senator Bob Hasegawa, a bill for a Washington State public bank (cooperative) has been passed by the Senate and moved [...]

4 comments, most recent 1 month ago

Masked Resistance

By Riley SweeneyOn Mar 05, 2021

We are a year into this pandemic and like most traumatic moments in history, it will soon be boiled down to a single concept in our collective consciousness. In my [...]

7 comments, most recent 2 months ago

The Importance of Our Public Fiber Optic Infrastructure

By Guest WriterOn Mar 03, 2021

[ Guest Writer Atul Deshmane, a PUD Commissioner, County Planning Commissioner, and Broadband Advisory Group (BAG) member, outlines some of the biggest infrastructure issues facing Bellingham today.]This article is [...]

7 comments, most recent 3 weeks ago

‘Public Banking Bill’ Voted Out Of Ways and Means Committee

By Dick ConoboyOn Mar 02, 2021

[This article is intended as an update to several previous articles listed below that should be read for the complete picture.]A second substitute bill (SSB5188) on a Washington State [...]

1 comment, most recent 2 months ago

After worker victories, The Bellingham Herald’s union is in place

By Ralph SchwartzOn Mar 02, 2021

McClatchy put up a fight, but newsroom employees at The Bellingham Herald and three other Washington newspapers got what they wanted -- a single union to represent workers at all [...]

3 comments, most recent 2 months ago

Emergency Management

By Guest WriterOn Feb 27, 2021

[Guest Writer Garrett O’Brien is a lifelong resident of Bellingham and lives with his wife Brittany and their three children in the Birchwood neighborhood. Garrett has worked in the [...]

5 comments, most recent 1 month ago

The Reality Of Zoom And Citizen Participation

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 21, 2021

We have entered into the age of Zoomification, book-ended by the Boomers and the Zoomers. We, the public, have now been consigned to being pixels on a screen with electronic [...]

2 comments, most recent 2 months ago

Letter: Secretary of Department of Corrections

By Letter WriterOn Feb 20, 2021

Dear Governor Inslee, I am writing to you today after learning your Department of Corrections (DOC) Secretary, Stephen Sinclair is resigning. I’ve watched over the decades as many people [...]

Public Banking For The State of Washington Inching Along

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 13, 2021

SB 5188, a substitute bill to establish a state public financial cooperative (no longer referred to as a bank) moved out of the Senate Committee on Business, Financial Services & Trade [...]

2 comments, most recent 2 months ago

Ranked-Choice Voting – Let’s Keep It Moving

By Stoney BirdOn Feb 12, 2021

Over 1,500 Washingtonians signed in “Pro” to the House State Government and Tribal Relations Committee’s February 8th hearing on HB 1156, sponsored by Rep. Kirsten Harris-Talley. On February 11th, the Committee [...]

1 comment, most recent 2 months ago

Cruising And Tourism: Wretched Excess

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 10, 2021

A friend in Juneau, Alaska sent me this article, “Towns and businesses across Alaska brace for a second summer without cruise ship tourists” which states in part: “[Alaska] saw more [...]

4 comments, most recent 2 months ago

Political Pretzel Logic without Cognitive Dissonance

By Guest WriterOn Feb 09, 2021

Ray Kamada guest writes. Ray is a retired atmospheric physicist from NOAA/DoD, and is now mostly involved in climate change and renewable energy studies. - - - - - [...]

5 comments, most recent 2 months ago