Recent Articles

Moral Injury Links Medicare Advantage Physicians To Combat Veterans

Morally significant double binds force doctors and combat soldiers into identical life and death quandaries, damaging their moral centers. To these two groups we can also add law enforcement officers.

Morally significant double binds force doctors and combat soldiers into identical life and death quandaries, damaging their moral centers. To these two groups we can also add law enforcement officers.

What can I do? Where can I hide from all this and not be found? What wings would take me high enough? How deep a hole would I have to dig? My shame for the evil I have done consumes me… I am soaked in blood-guilt, polluted, contagious… I am a pollutant, an offense to gods above. (Euripides, 416 BCE)

 

Several years ago on the occasion of Veterans Day, I wrote about the concept of moral injury in an article entitled “A Civilian Speaks to Veterans.” A piece, by Professor of Religion Kelly Denton-Borhaug, that appeared in TomDispatch, alerted me to the work being done by her on this issue at Moravian University in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. There, Dr. Denton-Borhaug is Program Director of Peace and Justice Studies and also Co-director of the Moravian University Humanities Fellowship.  She states:  

“Moral injury is not a psychological pathology.  It is the destruction of a person's moral center within the context of war.”  

So I should not have been surprised to find the above concept applied to Medicare Advantage, wherein doctors are forced to deal daily with life threatening situations whose outcomes are decided not by medical professionals but by profit-driven insurance companies (private corporations, hedge fund managers, or Ollie's Plumbing and Heating). In the June 2024 edition of The Retiree Advocate, Jaisri Lingappa explains this phenomena in an article entitled “Is Medicare Advantage Creating a Crisis of Conscience for Your Provider?”  Lingappa posits:

“Moral injury is the distress health-care providers feel when their personal ethos to heal suffering and, above all, do no harm conflicts with a corporate mandate to generate profits. In a seminal 2018 article (1) and their subsequent book on this topic (2), Dr. Wendy Dean and co-author Dr. Simon G. Talbot explained how moral injury among healthcare providers is analogous to veterans experiencing “anxiety and avoidance caused...by shame and guilt associated with perceived immoral conduct.” Importantly, moral injury is not the same as burnout. Recommendations for relieving burnout – e.g. time off, reduced hours, encouraging relaxation through meditation or hobbies – do not relieve the moral injury that providers feel when pressured to be the instrument of systems that betray their deeply held moral beliefs.”

A later article, “Reframing Clinician Distress: Moral Injury Not Burnout” by  Dr. Harold G. Koenig and Dr. Faten Al Zaben, looks at the symptoms exhibited by soldiers, physicians, and health care workers that demonstrate their commonality and their points of divergence, as shown in the Venn diagram at the beginning of this article. In the conclusion to their article, Koenig and Al Zaben provide an additional aspect of MI:

“We have also noted that MI occurs in first responders and others exposed to severe trauma that may have involved actions that transgressed moral beliefs or values, although regrettably, little research has been done in this regard.”

This quote brings to mind an article I wrote six years ago, “The Traumatization of Our Police,”  in which I expanded on an article, “The Police Are Traumatized,” by Alex Kelly, former editor at Truthdig. Kelly reports that,

“…police work is inherently traumatizing. Whether they ever have cause to reach for their guns or not, police officers are constantly subject to threats of violence. It is part of the water in which they swim. Left untreated, the consequences of trauma can be disastrous. Lengthy exposure disrupts normal brain functioning. It undermines our ability to think clearly and carefully and regulate our emotions. And it makes us more suspicious, less trusting and even paranoid. It increases the likelihood that we will respond to stressful experiences aggressively.”

But Kelly also mentions that few police officers avail themselves of treatment for their stress. In many cases involving their contacts with the public, police officers are caught between solidarity with their fellow officers, police department management, and their own personal moral center. By getting psychological help, officers risk breaking with other officers, those whom they depend upon to assist and protect them. Therein, the double bind, which leads to moral injury.

Three videos below on moral injury as understood in the cultures of the military, the police and health care practitioners.  

Related Links

Comments by Readers

Carol Follett

Jun 16, 2024

Thank you, Dick, for this insight on the corruption of our organisations and careers created and followed with an intent to serve. Medical professionals, police officers, and our soldiers are generally attracted to these careers to serve in what they perceive as a public good. The Affordable Care Act was also an attempt to serve the public good. However, these professions and laws are only as “good” as those in power choose to employ them. The extreme proffit culture in which we currently live is undermining and abusing our good intentions. 

We need to revisit the fact that corporations, wielding incredible political power, are not people - people have a moral center, corporations do not.

Read More...

Dick Conoboy

Jun 16, 2024

Carol,

Today’s large corporations are very much sociopathic in nature.  Whether it is the very nature of corporations that attracts or even creates sociopaths among its management or the entry of sociopathic leadership that demands a sociopathic corporate behavior, is not yet clear to me.  I expect that both feed off each other. 

These are some of the characteristics of sociopathy.  We can mentally consider these traits while considering large corporations and their leadership.   Examples might be Bezos or Musk and their corporate manifestations, Amazon or X.

  • Not understanding the difference between right and wrong.
  • Not respecting the feelings and emotions of others.
  • Constant lying or deception.
  • Being callous.
  • Difficulty recognizing emotion.
  • Manipulation.
  • Arrogance.
  • Violating the rights of others through dishonest actions.
  • Impulsiveness.
  • Risk-taking.
  • Difficulty appreciating the negative aspects of their behavior.
Read More...

M. Lynda Hanscome

Jun 16, 2024

Well said, Dick Conoboy.

Read More...

Dick Conoboy

Jun 17, 2024

This should be very interesting.

Dick

 

A PSARA Webinar

Is Medicare Advantage Driving Your Provider to Despair?

And Why Should You Care?

Tuesday, July 9, 5:00 p.m.

Join us on Tuesday, July 9, at 5 p.m.
PDT for a Webinar discussing moral
injury, featuring Dr. Carol Paris and Dr.
Diljeet Singh of Physicians for a Nation-
al Health Plan (PNHP).

To REGISTER for this webinar, click here:

https://us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_EkbwVHfJQsWaNLS6JHz-HQ

Read More...

Moral Injury Links Medicare Advantage Physicians To Combat Veterans

By Dick ConoboyOn Jun 16, 2024

Morally significant double binds force doctors and combat soldiers into identical life and death quandaries, damaging their moral centers. To these two groups we can also add law enforcement officers.

4 comments, most recent 1 week ago

Over A Half Trillion Dollars Stolen From Medicare - Sen. Patty Murray Is OK With That

By Dick ConoboyOn Jun 14, 2024

It is time to stop the “Real Steal” from Medicare.

3 comments, most recent 1 week ago

Nooksack Adjudication vs. State Water Law?

By Eric HirstOn Jun 14, 2024

Eric Hirst gives us a brief and clear explanation of the water adjudication process that is beginning now in Whatcom County

2 comments, most recent 1 week ago

The Scrap Heap - The Real Message

By David Netboy On Jun 12, 2024

Aggressive citizen involvement carried the day.

5 comments, most recent 1 week ago

The Wealth Of Real Estate Corporations Is Not Our Purpose For Being

By Guest WriterOn Jun 11, 2024

Build-for-profit, incarceration-inspired housing is destroying our souls.

10 comments, most recent 1 week ago

All Remaining ABC Scrap Metal Is On Ship

By John ServaisOn Jun 10, 2024

The last of the scrap metal is loaded on the ship and it will be gone from our town.

1 comment, most recent 1 week ago

A Walking Tour at the Core of the Explosion

By John ServaisOn Jun 10, 2024

A 54-photo tour of the ruptured pipe area of the Whatcom Creek explosion taken in July 1999.

1 comment, most recent 2 weeks ago

The Audio of the Pipeline Explosion

By John ServaisOn Jun 08, 2024

Below is an audio tape of 911 calls, emergency responders’ radio communications, and local radio coverage from June 10, 1999 when Whatcom Creek exploded in Bellingham

2 comments, most recent 2 weeks ago

Court Process for Defining Whatcom Water Rights Begins

By Guest WriterOn Jun 03, 2024

Whatcom County’s confusing water rights will be defined by court proceedings beginning now

1 comment, most recent 1 week ago

Memorial Day 2024 - Remembering My Friends

By Dick ConoboyOn May 25, 2024

If not killed-in-action, they are still dying from the effects of their service in Vietnam.

7 comments, most recent 3 weeks ago

More Broadbandwashing and Anti-Voter Secrecy

By Jon HumphreyOn May 25, 2024

The foam of secrecy hides all.

Water Rights

By Tip JohnsonOn May 02, 2024

Local presentations scheduled on a reasonable use framework for water resource management

A Resolution to Make Sure Nothing Gets Done

By Jon HumphreyOn Apr 09, 2024

Broadband-Washing: Greenwashing the Internet

6 comments, most recent 2 months ago

Moving Back from the Brink

By Gene MarxOn Apr 05, 2024

Pacific Northwest organizers join a global campaign to abolish all nukes and push for a city council resolution to start

4 comments, most recent 2 months ago

Medicare (Dis)Advantage - Even Hospitals Don’t Like It.

By Dick ConoboyOn Mar 31, 2024

If the hospitals are smelling a rat, so should Medicare (Dis)Advantage victims (AKA enrollees).

2 comments, most recent 1 week ago

The $5 Trillion National Infrastructure Bank Is Looking Better Every Day

By Dick ConoboyOn Mar 27, 2024

With such a bank in place, we would likely not be scrambling around and asking Congress for rebuild monies, as we are now with the catastrophic event involving the Francis Scott Key bridge on March 26, 2024.

Scrap metal shipping from Port dock ends this summer

By John ServaisOn Mar 25, 2024

Port of Bellingham commissioners terminate last 13 years of ABC Recycling lease

5 comments, most recent 2 months ago

COB - Your Interests vs. Corporate Interests

By Jon HumphreyOn Mar 18, 2024

No public fiber means we can’t compete with big telecom. EVER.

4 comments, most recent 2 months ago

The Insidious Creep of Medicare (Dis)Advantage

By Guest WriterOn Feb 25, 2024

Crappier coverage for us, even more money for insurance companies.

3 comments, most recent 3 months ago

Firing Up the War Machine

By Dianne FosterOn Feb 09, 2024

Who benefits? Palestinians are being slaughtered. Genocide. Gaza is being leveled.

6 comments, most recent 3 months ago