Topic: Coal, Oil & Trains (63)

Infinite Growth and Its Ecological Impact

Jason Hickel, anthropologist, author, and fellow of the Royal Society of the Arts, has written perhaps the best article I’ve read on the growth imperative and its ecological impact: The Nobel Prize for Climate Catastrophe.

The article is so well-written that I’m inclined to excerpt virtually the entire thing for this post (which I won’t do).

Here are a few excerpts that really require reading the article for context.

“All of this leads us back to a more fundamental question. Economists such as Nordhaus insist that perpetual GDP growth is necessary for human welfare. Three decades of delaying climate action have been justified on this principle. But is it even true? Is GDP growth really our only option?

“Remarkably, Nordhaus—like most orthodox economists—has never bothered to consider this question. The growth-is-good mantra is so baked into our consciousness that to question it seems almost crazy. Indeed, growthism is hegemonic to the point of transcending ideology. Politicians on the left and right alike hold it up as the single most important policy objective; they may quarrel about how to make growth happen, and how to distribute its yields, but on the question of growth itself there’s no daylight between them.

“In recent years, ecological economists have been staking out an alternative vision. We will have a much better chance of accomplishing our climate goals, they say, if rich countries abandon their pursuit of GDP growth. And if we do it right, we can not only protect human well-being but even improve it. Liberating ourselves from the growth imperative may be our best shot at flourishing through the 21st century.

We are at a crossroads. Nordhaus, and many world leaders, remain wedded to the obsolete dogmas of the last century. But scientists are clear that this is no longer good enough – and the rest of the world is ready for something better.”

About Larry Horowitz

Commenting member • Member since Jan 16, 2008

Comments by Readers

Dick Conoboy

Jan 07, 2019


Thanks to the reference to the Hickel article which I just read in its entirety.   I wrote about the problem of growth on these pages almost 6 months ago in  a piece called The Great Deceleration that so piqued the interest of our readers that not one person commented.  In my piece I quoted author Alex Jensen writing for Counterpunch who said, 

“ is precisely the increasing scale of economic activity – of ‘the economy’ – that is the heart of the multiple interlocking crises that beset societies and the earth today. The relentlessly expansionist logic of the system is inimical to life, to the world, even to genuine well-being. If we wish to instead honor, defend, and respect life and the world, we must upend that logic, and begin the urgent task of down-scaling economic activity and the system that drives it. We must embark upon the ‘Great Deceleration’.”

I called for a  Degrowth Management Act in Washington to replace the ridicously named Growth Management Act which, unfortunately, is still in force. 


Larry Horowitz

Jan 07, 2019

Dick, I have been following the work of Brian Czech, Herman Daly, and the staff of the Center for the Advancement of the Steady State Economy (CASSE) for more than a decade, and I have been posting their literature on various local sites and referring to it in comment letters for about that long.

In 2016, the Vermont legislature passed HCR 412 “House Concurrent Resolution Honoring the Center for the Advancement of the Steady State Economy Its Important Work,” including these two Whereas Clauses:

“Whereas, the long-term stability of a steady state economy requires its establishment at a size small enough to avoid the breaching of ecological and economic capacity, especially during supply shocks such as droughts and energy shortages; and

“Whereas, a steady state economy fosters economic development and an increase in human welfare through strategic changes in relative prominence of economic sectors, specific techniques, such as renewable energy usage, and an emphasis on social goals other than material production and consumption.”

The point is, we do not need to reinvent the wheel (though we desperately need new breakthrough energy technologies).  Organizations like CASSE and people like Alex Jensen exist as wayshowers.

The real issue is, and has always been, the concentration of wealth and power and the ability of the most powerful to maintain the status quo. 

How do we transition from where we are to where we need to be?  Will that involve an evolution?  Or will it require a revolution?  


Wendy Harris

Mar 01, 2019

Or, you could just talk to an actual ecologist trained in conservation science, or better yet, take any college ecology 101 class.  Economists act like they just discovered gravity. 

To comment, Log In or Register

Infinite Growth and Its Ecological Impact

By Larry HorowitzOn Jan 07, 2019

Jason Hickel, anthropologist, author, and fellow of the Royal Society of the Arts, has written perhaps the best article I’ve read on the growth imperative and its ecological impact: [...]

3 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Election recap: Conservatives start to make inroads on Whatcom Council

By Ralph SchwartzOn Nov 13, 2017

​No matter how you slice it, district-only voting is a good thing if you’re a conservative in Whatcom County. Right-wing politicos on the 2015 county Charter Review Commission managed to [...]

Fossil Fools

By Michael RiordanOn Oct 13, 2017

After recent months, when Hurricanes Harvey, Irma and Maria devastated Texas, Florida and Puerto Rico, and unprecedented wildfires torched the West from British Columbia to California, anyone who imagines that [...]

6 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Burping Tankers Spread Sulfurous Fumes

By Michael RiordanOn Jun 14, 2017

The smelly cloud of sulfurous fumes that wafted over Bellingham Saturday evening, June 3, was apparently not that unusual an occurrence. It happened due to an overpressure on the Italian oil [...]

2 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Will new BC government stop the proposed pipeline?

By John ServaisOn May 30, 2017

On Monday, May 29, our neighbors to the north, British Columbia, had a surprising and dramatic change in their government. With a parliamentary system, this can happen. Two minority parties cemented [...]

6 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Whatcom Sheriff’s facebook Search Warrant Is Withdrawn

By John ServaisOn Mar 13, 2017

This article has been updated from the original post at 3:40 p.m. Whatcom County Sheriff Elfo and the county prosecutor’s office have withdrawn their search warrant for facebook messages. [...]

Community Rights Movement Rising

By Stoney BirdOn Jan 28, 2017

Stoney Bird guest writes. In 2012, an initiative campaign for a Community Bill of Rights in Bellingham was part of a nationwide movement for local communities to reassert their rights, their [...]

4 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Being Thankful on Thanksgiving

By John ServaisOn Nov 24, 2016

Most - maybe all - reading this have much to be thankful for. Many may feel grief or despair because of the elections. They should not because what we have [...]

YES on I-732 Fits Conservative & Liberal Values

By John ServaisOn Nov 04, 2016

Beware the deceptive and very last minute anti-732 campaign. Vote YES on initiative 732. The Carbon Tax is really neutral as our sales taxes and other taxes will be reduced by [...]

Coal Trains Blocked by Local Protesters

By John ServaisOn Aug 28, 2016

Update: Mon, Aug 29, 8:30 a.m. In this morning's Bellingham Herald, not a single use of the words “coal” or “oil” in their article on the protest. The Herald referred [...]

3 comments, most recent 4 years ago

Breaking Free: A New Age Ghost Dance

By Guest WriterOn May 18, 2016

Jay Taber, a dedicated enviromental advocate, guest writes this critique of protest events, such as at the Anacortes oil refineries last weekend. This first posted on the Salish Sea Maritime [...]

2 comments, most recent 4 years ago

Herons or Oil: Which are long term?

By John ServaisOn May 14, 2016

Some folks from Bellingham who read this may also be participating in the kayaking and land protest at the Tesoro oil refinery near Anacortes. It is a coordinated protest with [...]

2 comments, most recent 4 years ago

No Coal Terminal at Cherry Point - Final

By John ServaisOn May 09, 2016

This morning, the Army Corps of Engineers released a simple press release. In plain language, Colonel Buck denies the Gateway Pacific Terminal project at Cherry Point. Col. Buck says he [...]

4 comments, most recent 4 years ago

OregonLNG quits: Cherry Point may be new target

By John ServaisOn Apr 18, 2016

Reliable sources tell me that Williams Pipeline Company is planning to apply for permits to extend a natural gas spur pipeline from their main pipeline at Sumas over to Cherry [...]

6 comments, most recent 4 years ago

BNSF: A casual approach to railroad safety

By John ServaisOn Apr 04, 2016

The coal train in the photo above is heading north along Bellingham Bay just above Clayton Beach. Notice how it seems to overhang the sandy bluff? That is because the [...]

2 comments, most recent 4 years ago

Cherry Point coal port development put on ice

By John ServaisOn Apr 01, 2016

The Seattle Times is reporting a decision by Cloud Peak Energy and SSA Marine to pause work on the Environmental Impact Statement for the proposed Cherry Point coal terminal. The [...]

3 comments, most recent 4 years ago

Fuller calls on Coast Guard to ‘stand on the right side of history’

By Guest WriterOn Mar 23, 2016

Rob Lewis guest writes this report. SEATTLE—During his March 17 appeal hearing, Matt Fuller delivered a detailed and unapologetic defense of his 22-hour occupation of the anchor chain on the [...]

Will Cherry Point coal port be denied this week?

By John ServaisOn Mar 16, 2016

The folks in Montana think the US Army Corps of Engineers will announce this week the denial of a permit for the mega coal port at Cherry Point. The Helena [...]

4 comments, most recent 4 years ago

Dems, GOP primed for legal fight over districts

By Ralph SchwartzOn Mar 15, 2016

Half a dozen Districting Committee meetings in the books, and what does Whatcom County have to show for them? One mystery and one thing we know all too well. First [...]

2 comments, most recent 4 years ago

The state of citizen journalism is strong: Two receive deArmond awards

By Ralph SchwartzOn Mar 11, 2016

The third annual Paul deArmond Citizen Journalism award dinner on Feb. 12 in Bellingham was bigger than ever—a bigger venue, more guests, a higher bar tab and, most notably, not [...]

2 comments, most recent 4 years ago