Topic: News Media (258)

Welcome to Elon Musk and His Takeover of Twitter

The fellow says he wants to make Twitter a better public forum by enhancing freedom of speech. Sounds great.

The fellow says he wants to make Twitter a better public forum by enhancing freedom of speech. Sounds great.

By

We should welcome Elon Musk's buyout of Twitter, officially completed this evening. Of all the social media venues, Twitter is the one used for politics and official government notices. Musk wants Twitter to be open to writers of all persuasions. He wants a viable forum for all of us to use for political discussion and public issues. This is a fine goal. Let's give him a fair chance to show what he can do. 

I founded Northwest Citizen over 27 years ago. It was a platform for citizen journalism and a counter to the awful reporting by the Bellingham Herald. I was not trying to compete with the Herald but to identify important public issues they were ignoring and to call them out when they lied. Now, NWCitizen is perhaps the oldest citizen journalism venue in the world. I know a few things about open public venues.

With the rise of social media over the past 20 years, it has been sad to see the trashy job facebook and many other venues did in fostering anger, deleting legitimate content, hiding threads from people, and basically causing chaos. All in the name of profit. Twitter offered some hope and did better than others, but the founders lost their way.  

The truth is, no one knows the right way to run a social media platform because we are still inventing it. But Twitter holds the promise of potentially being a worldwide forum for public issues. Musk is eager to try improving it. He has vision and has shown through his other businesses that he is not afraid to try new things, make mistakes, learn, and adjust. We should support his effort to improve it.

Musk is putting his own money into a project he believes will benefit humanity. He is risking billions for a good cause rather than spending billions on yachts, mansions, cars, or islands. His past endeavors have done enormous good for our world but that is another article. For now, I welcome his takeover of Twitter.

About John Servais

Citizen Journalist and Editor • Fairhaven, Washington USA • Member since Feb 26, 2008

Comments by Readers

Carol Follett

Oct 29, 2022

I appreciate your generosity in wanting to open the arena for an online information and conversation space, but I am afraid I cannot follow your level of trust for an overly wealthy, highly egotistical, white male whose wealth jeopardizes any hope of fairness to begin with.

If he wishes to genuinely create a “green space,” he should give his money away with no strings attached to such an open journalism experiment. Actually, his money would be much better spent in donating to an educational organisation teaching critical thinking skills, ferreting out self interest and bias, evaluating the validity of sources and developing fact checking skills.

There con be no democracy when wealth is unconstrained. Since Citizens United unplugged the money cask allowing unlimited money to flow to candidates, any hope of genuine, balanced representation is gone and with it laws protecting us from exploitation. It appears we have returned to an era of monopolies that remove the ballast of our ship and bring is into danger of sinking, lopsided in their visions. 

Diverse opinions, ideas, and people enrich society. Deep and honest, educated discussion with inclusive vision for all will move us to be creative, healthy, and mature people who may not only survive but thrive into the future. I do not believe this can happen under the weight of money moguls and their pet projects.

Read More...

Dick Conoboy

Oct 29, 2022

Carol,

I agree with your comments and have several of my own.  I have never joined Twitter because I thought at the start that it would be a place where people would snap and snarl and lie to one another in snippets of several hundred characters (not words).  How would this even promise to be a platform for the exchange of rational thought or considered commentary?  And so it turns out that a tweet has an average reading level of the 6th grade.  Surprised?   The level of thought and critical thinking is likely hovering over kindergarten.

It’s a failed venture that has proved disastrous for civil discourse and virtually devoid of any meaningful dialogue.  That Musk will have any better luck in controlling this bucking bronco of a “social network” is highly problematic even if he wants to… which is, in itself, unknown.   Being a billionaire does not make anyone more socially, politically or culturally more competent, to wit:  Musk, Gates, Jobs, Zuckerberg, Murdoch, Koch(s), Bezos, Buffet, Ballmer, et cetera and ad nauseam.  If they joined together in a club it would be named Soporifics Я Us

Billionaires Won’t Save the World, Just Look at Elon Musk”, an article by Sam Pizzigati written in 2018 was precient.  ” Indeed, if Musk really wanted to ensure humankind a sustainable future, he wouldn’t be plotting escapes to Mars or marketing flamethrowers to the masses. He’d be challenging the global economic status quo that’s left him phenomenally rich and our world phenomenally unequal.”  We can now add Twitter to Mars colonies and flamethrowers.

 

Read More...

Tip Johnson

Oct 29, 2022

If Twitter v.musk reinstates the twaitorist tweeter in chief I will remain at least skeptical

Read More...

John Servais

Oct 29, 2022

“Why would I leave Twitter? It’s like living in NY and not taking the subway. Sure it’s dirty and smells bad, but it’s how you get places.”  -  Dave Winer

Read More...

Carol Follett

Oct 30, 2022

Thank you for sharing the link to the Sam Pitzzigoti article! I love his idea of a maximum income.  Of course, fair taxation would bring that about, I think. Although I am not an economist, I know there is something greviously wrong with a system that brought us to jepordy in our dependence on a foreign power for essential supplies, is reducing our ability to choose our grocers (Kroger-Albertsons mega-merger could cause more US food deserts, experts say) and, of course, leaves so many without decent homes in which to shelter. The solutions requires us to be well and honestly informed and to be able to elect representatives who will do what is best for the health of us all, not of a corporation or individual meglamaniacs

Read More...

John Servais

Nov 20, 2022

Yesterday, Elon Musk enabled former president Donald Trump to resume posting on Twitter.  I think that the right move for Elon for two reasons.  It is a smart business move as it will keep and attract many other subsribers - both those supportive and opposed to Trump.  And it enables a voice that is prominent in national and world politics.  As the liberals and Ds fret and clutch their pearls, we should not care that T is back on Twitter.  Let us counter T’s scurrilous words and lies with effective arguments.  

Josh Marshall has a short post this morning on his Talking Points Memo website - but it is behind a paywall.   Josh is, imo, one of the very best observers of our natioal political machinations.  His is a very independent news media organization.   

Josh writes, “Yes, if Trump could be systematically barred from all channels of mass communication in the country his influence would probably go down. But that is hardly a realistic or even meritorious strategy, especially in a country where 4 out of 9 people want him to be President.“

As Josh points out, Twitter is a private company and is in no way our national town square - and we should not think of it that way.  If we do not like what a billionaire is doing then we can go to another social media platform.  My guess is a one or more organizations are working on starting a competitor to Twitter right now. 

Josh ends by suggesting “The only dignified response to this is a studied indifference.”

Read More...
To comment, Log In or Register

Welcome to Elon Musk and His Takeover of Twitter

By John ServaisOn Oct 27, 2022

The fellow says he wants to make Twitter a better public forum by enhancing freedom of speech. Sounds great.

6 comments, most recent 6 months ago

Dear Vlad…

By Tip JohnsonOn Jul 08, 2022

Anon letters trying to intimidate us and our writers are non starters.

9 comments, most recent 10 months ago

Cascadia Daily News Broadband Article Falls Short

By Jon HumphreyOn Feb 25, 2022

The CDN internet article doesn’t question “high-speed” or “affordable” or “coming soon” in Whatcom County.

3 comments, most recent 1 year ago

We Welcome the Cascadia Daily News

By John ServaisOn Jan 23, 2022

We have a new newspaper located in Bellingham with the goal of covering our three counties and lower British Columbia.

1 comment, most recent 1 year ago

Cascadia Daily News Is Arriving Soon!

By Dick ConoboyOn Jan 10, 2022

At last, a newspaper of substance, unhindered by imbedded corporate interests

3 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Letter: The Social Security Crisis Is a Lie

By Letter WriterOn Nov 28, 2021

Shannon Skinner debunks the Social Security crisis

Ron Judd Bids Farewell to Seattle

By John ServaisOn Sep 06, 2021

Learning more about the managing editor of a new daily news source in Bellingham, coming January 1.

1 comment, most recent 1 year ago

Cascadia Daily News to Begin In January

By John ServaisOn Aug 06, 2021

Bellingham to get a locally owned and professional daily news publication beginning in January 2022.

7 comments, most recent 1 year ago

YouTube’s Subversion Of The Bellingham City Council

By Dick ConoboyOn Aug 04, 2021

Playing along with YouTube is a losing game for Bellingham. It is time to break the ties that bind … and blind.

5 comments, most recent 1 year ago

The Monumentally Moronic Mindlessness Of YouTube

By Dick ConoboyOn Jul 24, 2021

It is time for Bellingham City Hall to take control by dumping YouTube for having taken down a video of a City Council meeting.

8 comments, most recent 1 year ago

After worker victories, The Bellingham Herald’s union is in place

By Ralph SchwartzOn Mar 02, 2021

With a recent dispute between the newspaper’s reporters and management over, the real work can begin.

3 comments, most recent 2 years ago

City Hall homeless camp cleared out a day early

By John ServaisOn Jan 28, 2021

Bellingham started clearing 24 hours earlier than announced days ago. Antifa has showed up in numbers to provoke. Heavy police presence

2 comments, most recent 2 years ago

McClatchy seeks to break up union that includes Bellingham Herald staff

By Ralph SchwartzOn Jan 11, 2021

While McClatchy appears ready to accept unionization among the Herald’s content creators, it would be on their terms.

5 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Unanswered Questions From Oil Train Wreck at Custer

By John ServaisOn Dec 29, 2020

Something is amiss regarding the BNSF oil-train wreck in Custer on Dec 22, 2020. Why, after a week, are there no answers and a cause?

11 comments, most recent 2 years ago

‘Now we will have a voice’—Bellingham Herald’s newsroom joins union

By Ralph SchwartzOn Dec 22, 2020

After a takeover by a hedge fund with a history of decimating newspapers, The Bellingham Herald’s news staff is taking a stand.

2 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Mainstream Media won’t Say this about Hong Kong

By Ho See-wingOn Jun 13, 2020

Hong Kong freedom protestors are against Black Lives Matters protestors?? Our USA corporate media have not told us that. Ho See-wing links us to more news sources.

2 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Bellingham Herald Reprints Seattle Times Article - But With Edit

By John ServaisOn May 29, 2020

How the Herald reports Bellingham news by reprinting articles from the Seattle Times - but cannot even do that honestly.

1 comment, most recent 3 years ago

PeaceHealth Sets Up Straw Man of Dr Lin

By John ServaisOn Apr 06, 2020

Wherein we pick our way through the evolving versions of the PeaceHealth letter/ad in Sunday’s Bellingham Herald. And cover their obsessive efforts to marginalize Dr Lin.

5 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Three ways to cover a whistleblower story

By John ServaisOn Mar 20, 2020

How the Seattle Times, Bellingham Herald and this site, NWCitizen, reported on the issues raised in Dr. Ming Lin’s letter to Charles Prosper, the CMO of PeaceHealth.

1 comment, most recent 3 years ago

Bellingham Herald to end Saturday publication

By Dianne FosterOn Jun 25, 2019

Dianne Foster expresses her thoughts and regrets as the Bellingham Herald announces the pending cancellation of Saturday newspapers.

1 comment, most recent 3 years ago