Topic: Health (218)

The Long History of Corporate Fraud and Abuse in Medicare

• Topics: Health, Health, Health, Health,

[The following is reprinted from The Retiree Advocate, monthly newsletter of Puget Sound Advocates for Retirement Action (PSARA).  Guest Writer is Ana M. Malinow, MD, a member of PSARA. She is a retired pediatrician, a past president of Physicians for a National Health Program, and a lead organizer for National Single Payer]

The passage of Medicare in 1965 was historic for covering the medical needs of seniors. But it also created conditions highly attractive for the providers of health care, who the government desperately wanted to accommodate. This arrangement resulted in the federal government surrendering the terms of the program and its costs to private health insurance companies, hospitals, and doctors, who would shape Medicare to maximize their profits at the expense of taxpayers from 1965 until today. A program originally designed to protect seniors from financial ruin due to medical costs, financed by the government and delivered through private doctors and hospitals, Medicare became a trough for corporations free to gorge themselves through sanctioned fraud and abuse. 

In the five decades since the passage of Medicare, the federal government has continued to accommodate health insurance companies, hospitals, and doctors. From the get-go, Medicare agreed to pay hospitals according to their costs instead of a negotiated rate. Doctors were paid according to “usual, customary, and reasonable” charges, which contributed to unchecked costs. Unrestrained accommodation to hospitals and doctors skyrocketed costs and resulted in many of the financial “reforms” that started a decade after the passage of Medicare, and which have persisted to this day.

The following three decades saw a series of attempts to control costs of Medicare. The 70s saw the rise of Health Maintenance Organizations, responsible for introducing for-profit corporations into the US health care system, which until then, had been dominated by the “non-profit” Blues. The 80s gave us diagnosis-related group hospital reimbursement, which incentivized hospitals to shorten hospital stays to increase profits. The 90s introduced Medicare Plus Choice, which resulted in the creation of mostly for-profit middlemen to manage the care of beneficiaries on Medicare. 

In 2003, with the passage of the Medicare Modernization Act, the floodgates to private insurance plans, now called Medicare Advantage (MA), were flung open. Enrollment in these plans grew steadily and aggressively, from about 5 million beneficiaries in 2003, to 28 million beneficiaries today, or half of all beneficiaries. Reasons for its popularity are obvious: no or low premium for Part B (outpatient costs) and Part D (prescription drug plans) and extra benefits prohibited in Traditional Medicare (TM) – the non-MA part of Medicare – such as some vision, hearing, dental, fitness, telehealth, over-the-counter items, meals, gym memberships, and transportation benefits. 

But the real reason why these plans are so popular has less to do with enrollee benefits and more to do with industry benefits – all fraudulent, all legal. Medicare sets rates for MA enrollees above those for TM – meaning Medicare pays MA plans more for enrollees than for enrollees in TM. There are bogus quality bonuses and rebates, again all fraudulent, all legal. MA plans game risk scores (making healthy patients look sicker, increasing the payment rate, but not increasing the amount of health care provided), engage in favorable selection (selecting for the healthiest patients and dropping the sickest ones), create narrow networks that often exclude cancer centers of excellence, and impose prior authorization delays and outright denials of care for millions of beneficiaries despite meeting Medicare coverage rules. A recent New York Times article revealed that 8 out of 10 of the largest MA plans submitted inflated bills to Medicare. Overpayments to MA plans from 2010 to 2019 totaled $106 billion – fraud the government has little appetite to recoup. 

This waste and fraud threaten to deplete the Medicare Hospital Insurance Trust Fund by 2028. In the same New York Times article, journalists Abelson and Sanger-Katz write, "additional [upcoding] diagnoses led to $12 billion in overpayments in 2020 – enough to cover hearing and vision care for every American over 65." For the industry, it’s a sweet deal, made sweeter by incessant and often misleading ads during the annual Open Enrollment period, many featuring former NFL or aging Hollywood stars. 

The industry, not content with just half of the Medicare pie, has already gobbled up more. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), tasked with the responsible stewardship of Medicare, has been secretly privatizing TM through schemes such as the Medicare Shared Savings Program, Accountable Care Organizations, and most recently, through ACO REACH. Some ACO REACH participants have a history of Medicare fraud, but Medicare continues to sign contracts with them.

These schemes are developed by the Innovation Center, whose mandate is to develop payment models that lower costs while not worsening care. Models, including ACO REACH, are given “safe harbor” from certain fraud and abuse laws, including the Federal Anti-Kickback Statute, which makes it unlawful for a person to refer government-paid patients for medical services in exchange for payment. It seems like Innovation models cannot lower costs or improve patient care without fraud and abuse.

The aim of the Innovation Center is to have 100 percent of TM beneficiaries in a “care relationship with accountability for quality and total cost of care by 2030.”

“Accountability for quality and cost of care” is how Medicare gets privatized – by inserting private equity, venture capitalists, and for-profit insurance plans into a public program. In 1965, Medicare was threatened by the financial interests of insurance companies, hospitals, and doctors. Today, we are faced with the final iteration of this threat, where corporations take over Medicare completely for their own profit, sanctioned by the government. And all by 2030.

About Guest Writer

Citizen Journalist • Member since Jun 15, 2008

Comments by Readers

M. Lynda Hanscome

May 05, 2023

I agree with Dr. Malinow completely.  The PeaceHealth ACO-REACH scam stole my health file and enrolled me in the first iteration of this for-profit without my knowledge or consent.  It is all about MONEY.  I have TM and an excellent supplementary insurance (Tri-Care-for-Life).  But now PH is nothing more than and HMO that is that is defrauding Medicare out of millions of dollars and severely limiting patient care.

I have caught PH upcoding my occasional high blood pressure to put me in a higher risk group for more money from Medicare.  The Mayo Clinic calls HBP as “common condition.”  PH ignored that logic and have since put me in a category called “chronic disease.”  The “fix” that was presented in writing to me was that I agree to a one-on-one counselling session with a nurse practitioner.  Yes, really.  I agree with the writer of the article and that this corporate greed is the kiss of death to Traditional Medicare.

And PH is busy eliminating competition in the Bellingham area.  They are disgusting.  I have been fighting with PH for well over a year to be removed from the secret list of ‘participants.’  Maybe strength in numbers is a better option and it is pitiful that seniors who have given and given more to others and their communities in their lifetimes now have to scramble to fight a system that is corrput from the top down.  Very sad.  Thanks for your article, Dr. Malinow.


To comment, Log In or Register

The Long History of Corporate Fraud and Abuse in Medicare

By Guest WriterOn May 05, 2023

[The following is reprinted from The Retiree Advocate, monthly newsletter of Puget Sound Advocates for Retirement Action (PSARA). &...

1 comment, most recent 4 months ago

Restoring Health of Land and Water—Bellingham Style

By David Netboy On Apr 30, 2023

Toxic waste, scrap recycling, jarring noise, and dubious processes on the waterfront: How did this happen?

10 comments, most recent 1 month ago

City Council Review of Rental Registration and Inspection Ordinance

By Dick ConoboyOn Apr 25, 2023

A review and update of Bellingham’s rental registration and inspection program is long overdue.

10 comments, most recent 4 months ago

How Would Abortion Ban Impact Whatcom County?

By David A. SwansonOn Apr 17, 2023

In 2020, there were 464.29 abortions per 1,000 pregnancies among women aged 15-19 in Whatcom County.

2 comments, most recent 5 months ago

Ban All Firearms

By Dick ConoboyOn Apr 10, 2023

Ban them all. Forever. Every single, solitary firearm in the U.S.

18 comments, most recent 4 months ago

Port Priorities Subvert Their Own Plan

By David Netboy On Apr 01, 2023

David Netboy writes: So how, exactly, does ABC Scrap Metal “restore the health of the land and water” on our waterfront?

11 comments, most recent 5 months ago

Wildflowers in Santa Ynez

By Guest WriterOn Mar 15, 2023

Garrett O’Brien guest writes. And just how do we get out of this housing mess?

21 comments, most recent 5 months ago

Growth of Medicare’s ACO Reach Scam Halted

By Dick ConoboyOn Mar 12, 2023

The program appears to be dying of self-inflicted wounds that were long predicted. Supporters stiffened their spines instead, ignoring the obvious blood loss.

11 comments, most recent 4 months ago

Rise of Medicare Advantage – Creation of a Myth

By Guest WriterOn Mar 06, 2023

Millions of Medicare recipients have already been schnookered into Medicare Advantage. Don’t be a victim. Fight back.

6 comments, most recent 6 months ago

Call To Action On Medicare (Dis)Advantage!

By Dick ConoboyOn Mar 02, 2023

If we do not speak out NOW on the privatization of Medicare, the system will effectively be eaten alive from within.

3 comments, most recent 6 months ago

NWCitizen Journalist Down, But Certainly Not Out

By NWCitizen ManagementOn Feb 28, 2023

Stoney Bird, local writer and activist, was severely injured in a fall at this home. He has helped many. Now it is our time to return the support.

3 comments, most recent 6 months ago

A Cruel Joke From The VA and Congress

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 27, 2023

At least with a real joke, you get to laugh. Here, the government seem to laugh at you.

7 comments, most recent 6 months ago

“Social Security And Medicare Are Off The Books Now”

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 09, 2023

This is a quote from President Biden during his State of the Union address on February 7th, 2023. Your bullshit meter ought to be in the red now.

7 comments, most recent 7 months ago

Traditional Medicare - The Promise Is In Peril

By Guest WriterOn Jan 31, 2023

Excellent and succinct overview of Traditional Medicare, now under a very real threat. People are now waking up!

4 comments, most recent 7 months ago

Our Throw-Away Military Service Personnel

By Dick ConoboyOn Dec 26, 2022

Holiday Greetings to the troops. A middle finger.

10 comments, most recent 8 months ago

Medicare Part C - The “C” Is For Crap

By Dick ConoboyOn Nov 27, 2022

Part C is really for sh*t but that word does not start with a “C.”

2 comments, most recent 9 months ago

A Civilian Speaks To Veterans

By Dick ConoboyOn Nov 11, 2022

A must-read for anyone who knows a war veteran… and anyone who never met one.

10 comments, most recent 10 months ago

Here We Go Again

By Guest WriterOn Nov 02, 2022

A lifetime dealing with abortion, an account by a lifelong advocate.

6 comments, most recent 10 months ago

Letter: Medicare Advantage

By Letter WriterOn Oct 17, 2022

John O’Neil writes about use of our Bellingham Public Library for promoting destructive health plans.

Sefzik Public Safety Forum - Anecdotes “Я” Us

By Dick ConoboyOn Oct 05, 2022

Monologues and anecdotes are not the essence of a forum.

4 comments, most recent 10 months ago