Topic: Climate (130)

Is Hydrogen the Answer?

The truth is out there; Jon Humphrey has researched the issues and concisely compiled the results.

The truth is out there; Jon Humphrey has researched the issues and concisely compiled the results.

By
• Topics: Climate, Climate, Climate, Climate,

Poorly Researched Hydrogen-Hype Article from CDN

Over the years, I have corrected many tech articles, and based on the recent article about hydrogen, published in Cascadia Daily News, I need to again provide some guidance and clarify some issues. Here is an overview of where we’re really at with hydrogen and why it isn’t even close to a silver bullet energy solution or, in most cases, even practical.

 There is no question that we need to get away from fossil fuels. In fact, we probably never really needed them. Electric cars grew up almost in tandem with gas powered vehicles at first. In fact, by 1900, electric cars made up about a 1/3rd of the American car fleet. The history of how we ended up with petroleum is a mixture of technological glitches, Ford’s initiation of mass production, and the discovery of oil in Texas making gas cheap. Gas stations spread  across the U.S. while battery technology lagged behind. Unfortunately, hydrogen may be a modern form of the same problem: a wolf in sheep’s clothing where a seemingly benevolent fuel is covering up an impractical, dirty, and unsustainable production and distribution process. 

According to the book “Hot Mess” by Matt Winning, “It takes about four times as much electricity to make hydrogen as it does just to use the same electricity to charge a battery or run a heat pump.” Since most of the energy used in structures is for heating and cooling, and since heat pumps help with both, hydrogen doesn’t make sense when compared to just using electricity directly. 

When it comes to cars, charging a battery from a renewable energy power source is about 80% efficient, while using hydrogen can be 40% efficient or less, depending on which part of the Hydrogen Rainbow your hydrogen came from. 

   Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe. It is also considered a “very clingy gas,” and is often found bound to other elements like the oxygen in water (H2O). In order to get the hydrogen out of water, you must electrocute it in a process known as electrolysis, which requires electricity generated from some source. The source that is used is what creates the “Hydrogen Rainbow.”

The Hydrogen Rainbow - a 12 minute video.

Gray Hydrogen - This is hydrogen made using fossil fuels, usually natural gas. The vast majority of hydrogen made today, about 90%, is Gray Hydrogen. This process actually produces more emissions than just burning the natural gas directly.

Blue Hydrogen (aka greenwashing hydrogen) - This type of hydrogen production hypes itself as environmentally friendly. Blue Hydrogen again uses fossil fuels to break out the hydrogen, but the technology used to store the excess CO2 often produces even more emissions. According to Cornell’s Dr. Robert Howarth, “Turns out the greenhouse gas footprint of Blue Hydrogen is actually worse than if you just burned the natural gas directly instead… The goal is to keep selling fossil fuels to the world while pretending it’s going to get better.” Blue Hydrogen isn’t environmentally friendly at all.

Green Hydrogen - This is the only type of hydrogen production that may make sense. In this scenario, renewable energy is used to make hydrogen. However, in almost every case it makes more sense to use the electricity to simply run a heat pump or charge a battery instead of trying to make hydrogen. And even though the devices that split water molecules into hydrogen and oxygen are getting cheaper, at the same time, the technologies around batteries and heat pumps are also getting better. 

Hydrogen Transportation 

Hydrogen is a small atom. This makes it difficult to work with, especially when being transported long distances. As with all of our pipeline systems, efficiency will be negatively affected by leaks and other losses during transportation. Like with natural gas, we can expect leaks to worsen over time.

Fossil Fuel Companies Love This Idea

A big red flag to everyone should be that fossil fuel companies love the idea of hydrogen. BP is even considering a hydrogen facility of their own at Cherry Point. Remember the Cherry Point coal terminal?

Another Canadian Company?!

Just as our “leaders” are considering an unnecessary and toxic Canadian owned waterfront metal-recycling facility that will exude poisonous forever chemicals for years to come, according to the CDN article, “AtlaGas, a gas utility company based in Canada” would like to do the same. If a hydrogen plant comes to Whatcom County it will be owned by another Canadian company. Apparently word is out in Canada that Bellingham/Whatcom County is the place to go if you want to work with a government that has loose environmental regulations and values profit over the wishes and health of its citizens.

2050?!

And, of course, all of this is taking too long. Most of the projections for being able to use this technology in a significant way, are for mid-century. Unfortunately, this is about 20 years after we actually need it to work, which is by 2030.

Three Suggested Solutions

 These things are available to us now and make sense for the future.

  1. All new public buildings must have solar, batteries, and be part of Virtual Power Plants (VPPs are alliances of local generating units, such as wind or solar, that form networks capable of monitoring, forecasting, optimizing, and sharing surplus power. This includes schools.)
  2. Insulation (the reasons for this seems self-evident)
  3. Heat Pumps not AC. Heat pumps can be run directly off renewables and will help cool and heat buildings. Remember that until recently, buildings here were built without AC because we didn’t need it.

Electric Vs. Hydrogen

In Transportation: For passenger vehicles there is no doubt that electric vehicles are better. The main argument against purely electric vehicles is charge time. However, the charge time for batteries has gone down greatly and continues to do so. It currently costs an average of about $3 to $5 to charge your electric car at home; the equivalent in hydrogen (if you even had the infrastructure) would be about the same as the cost of gas today.  Using batteries in semi-trucks, buses, and other large vehicles will make more sense than hydrogen by the time it is ready for prime-time. It will also save us the enormous complexities of building a hydrogen system. 

Aerospace? The jury is still out on this one for me. It seems more important to get electric trains and buses into use, like France has done, targeting high-speed rail to replace most short and mid-range flights.

In Steel Production: With 8% of CO2 emissions being linked to steel production, I’ll admit hydrogen seems like an alluring solution. However, you can also run electric smelters directly from renewables.

In Shipping: Container ships could easily incorporate renewables, like solar panels and batteries, into the containers themselves. Hydrogen does take up less space though, so the jury is also still out on this one as well.

  So Why The Big Push for Hydrogen?

Hydrogen will allow wealthy special interests to maintain control of the distribution of a critical resource, like they do now with petroleum products. Hydrogen is complex to make, transport, and distribute just like petroleum products. So the wealthy and powerful and politically connected see a way to invest in a new fuel that will allow them to maintain the same stranglehold on our civilization as the old fossil fuels.

On the other hand, renewables and Virtual Power Plants allow us to decentralize the production of power, which is, in fact, significantly better. While PSE has a natural gas plant that is about 60% efficient, they also have up to 50% transmission loss getting that energy to you. VPPs allow us to eliminate many electrical transmissions losses and become individually energy independent. The powers that be want us chained to a profit center they control, so they push for a complicated system like hydrogen.

No Energy Is Really Green

We should all remember that no energy is truly green. Even the renewable energy technologies I discuss here have both an environmental and human impact. For instance, 70% of the battery material used in rechargeable batteries comes from economic-slaves in the Congo.

Local politicians who are backing hydrogen production for Washington include Governor Jay Inslee, Representative Alex Ramel, County Executive Satpal Sidhu and PUD Commissioner Atul Deshmane.

About Jon Humphrey

Citizen Journalist • Bellingham • Member since May 23, 2017

Comments by Readers

Dick Conoboy

Oct 27, 2023

When I was growing up in the 50s, a very old woman, who was always dressed in black and had a face powdered white, drove an all black electric car as pictured here.  It had no steering wheel.  It did have a tiller.  She would make a ghostly appearance as she drove past my house in total silence, sitting stiffly upright and steering with the tiller that was not readily visible.  One might be persuaded it was a dead person driving the car.   She was both behind the times and ahead of the times.

Read More...

Atul Deshmane

Oct 27, 2023

This was a mostly good article.

I am not a blanket supporter of hydrogen. I have actually worked on several projects related to hydrogen energy. There are very few cases where hydrogen is a useful energy storage solution.

There is potential where green hydrogen could be produced in our County and used to substitute for grey hydrogen usage. I would be supportive of that. It is an incremental improvement. 

Most virtual power plant solutions require access to distribution and markets. There is apparently an effort by PSE to support virtual power plants. I am curious about that.

One of the reasons people embrace hydrogen is that we are attracted to ideas that seem like a panacea and as pointed out in the article there is no panacea.

There is nothing we can do that is better than conservation!

Read More...

Tip Johnson

Oct 27, 2023 Read More...

Joseph Wilson

Oct 29, 2023

I enjoyed your interesting and informative article.

However, your warning that it should be a big red flag that BP is considering building a hydrogen facility at their Cherry Point Refinery seems misplaced. You implied that it had to be a bad thing because, “Remember the Cherry Point coal terminal?”

What a foolish statement for two reasons.
First, a hydrogen plant at Cherry Point is not a new thing. The refinery has had a hydrogen plant ever since it first started up 52 years ago. Have you considered the possibility that they may be interested in updating their hydrogen manufacturing process to current state of the art technology?
Secondly, are you not aware that the proposed Cherry Point coal terminal project you referred to had nothing to do with BP, nor the refinery? While it is true the project was propose to be built in the same Cherry Point Industrial District, the mere sharing of the words “Cherry Point” in a title should not be sufficient reason to link the BP refinery with the coal terminal project proposed by a completely differnt company.

I believe you have a lot of good insight to offer the readership, but in the future you might want to consider limiting your editorial comments to topics where you have relevent knowledge.

Read More...

Jon Humphrey

Oct 29, 2023

Thanks for your comments Joseph. Yes, I am aware of the points you made about the coal terminal. Still as you point out, it would have used Cherry Point. The overall point is that fossil fuel companies have taken advantage of us. Even “state of the art” Hydrogen is a bad idea. A gas engine may be 25% to 35% efficient, hydrogen 40% to 48%, electric 80%. Sure, the electricity has to be green too for it to really make sense. I’d love to talk to a BP engineer more about your take on energy. I believe in finding the truth. I probably won’t agree with you, but as Americans we should have open, honest, debates at this critical time in our history. I’ve learned that this is something the PUD is very bad at and most of our public institutions don’t believe in. See the big telecom rep. filled “Broadband Advisory Group.”

Read More...
To comment, Log In or Register

Is Hydrogen the Answer?

By Jon HumphreyOn Oct 26, 2023

The truth is out there; Jon Humphrey has researched the issues and concisely compiled the results.

5 comments, most recent 5 months ago

Renewed Push for a National Infrastructure Bank

By Dick ConoboyOn Jul 28, 2023

This legislation calls for a $5 trillion National Infrastructure Bank that will finance the nation’s infrastructure needs without involving the budget or adding to the national debt.

4 comments, most recent 7 months ago

Restoring Health of Land and Water—Bellingham Style

By David Netboy On Apr 30, 2023

Toxic waste, scrap recycling, jarring noise, and dubious processes on the waterfront: How did this happen?

10 comments, most recent 8 months ago

The Problems WTA Electric Buses Don’t Have

By Jon HumphreyOn Apr 15, 2022

“Alarmist” article is unfair to needed new technology

3 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Agent Orange and Vietnam Veterans, Their Children, and Grandchildren

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 22, 2022

Agent Orange is the “gift” that keeps giving.

3 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Delta Blues

By Michael RiordanOn Oct 25, 2021

Being a personal reflection on the impacts of the pernicious variant coronavirus.

10 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Covid Vaccine Booster Shots: Immoral or Necessary?

By Guest WriterOn Sep 28, 2021

Is it boosting* from the world’s poor to get a booster in the U.S.?

4 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Whatcom Citizens for Responsible Technology

By Jon HumphreyOn Jun 26, 2021

A new and local county wide technology group of Internet and broadband experts has been formed. Jon explains why and lists the members.

2 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Why Participate?

By Jon HumphreyOn May 17, 2021

An essay on climate change, millennials’ concerns, and large corporations and governments complacently stealing our kids futures.

5 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Variant Virus Strains Hit the County

By Michael RiordanOn May 08, 2021

The more contagious and possibly more deadly B.1.1.7 and P.1 coronavirus strains appear to be leaking down into Whatcom County from British Columbia.

10 comments, most recent 2 years ago

A Variant Virus Outbreak in Whatcom County?

By Michael RiordanOn Mar 12, 2021

Fourteen February cases of the B.1.1.7 variant coronavirus strain suggest that it is beginning to surge in the county.

10 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Unanswered Questions From Oil Train Wreck at Custer

By John ServaisOn Dec 29, 2020

Something is amiss regarding the BNSF oil-train wreck in Custer on Dec 22, 2020. Why, after a week, are there no answers and a cause?

11 comments, most recent 3 years ago

The Great Conjunction

By Deb GaberOn Dec 15, 2020

A conjunction occurs when two astronomical objects appear to line up. A great conjunction is when that happens with Jupiter and Saturn.

Coronavirus and Community

By Michael RiordanOn Oct 31, 2020

The novel coronavirus also attacks our need for community, which is the antidote to the epidemic of toxic individualism that has begun afflicting much of middle America.

6 comments, most recent 3 years ago

WWU Plans For Winter Quarter Beginning January 5th

By Dick ConoboyOn Oct 17, 2020

Winter quarter at WWU will look much the same as the fall quarter with mostly online classes.

State Government Skewing Internet Test to Favor Telecoms

By Jon HumphreyOn Aug 07, 2020

WA State Department of Commerce Internet Access Test is a Scam to Protect Big Telecom

7 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Update on the COVID-19 Warning System for San Juan County

By David A. SwansonOn Jul 18, 2020

So far, so good for San Juan County. The July 4th holiday visitors have not led to either a “Yellow” or “Red” alert for covid-19 cases among its residents

Is “Being Republican” a Risk to One’s Health and the Health of Others?

By David A. SwansonOn Jul 03, 2020

Along with potential “super-spreader” venues, rates of interaction, and other factors, “being Republican” also could represent a COVID-19 risk factor.

6 comments, most recent 3 years ago

Revisiting the Estimation of Unconfirmed Cases of COVID-19 in Whatcom County

By David A. SwansonOn Jun 27, 2020

Authors find that their method produces estimates of unconfirmed cases consistent with an announcement by the CDC that there are ten times more cases than reported.

A Tale of 39 Counties: Re-opening Washington and Political Orientation

By David A. SwansonOn Jun 21, 2020

Where in Washington are the COVID-19 case increases higher? Republican-leaning counties or Democratic leaning counties?

12 comments, most recent 3 years ago