Topic: War & Peace (187)

How Our Community Can Welcome Our Troops Home

Christopher Brown guest writes how traditional communal warrior reintegration practices could help our returning combat veterans.

Christopher Brown guest writes how traditional communal warrior reintegration practices could help our returning combat veterans.

Guest Writer: Christopher Brown is a U.S. Marine combat veteran of Iraq & Afghanistan and Purple Heart recipient.  He is currently pursuing a Masters Degree in Social Work through a part time program at the University of Washington.  He is also the director of the local non-profit group, Growing Veterans.

- - - -

Introduction

I am a military combat veteran who has been exposed to multiple traumas in Iraq and Afghanistan. I am planning a career counseling other combat veterans with Post-Traumatic Stress (PTS) and am focusing my research on comparing the approaches of Western medicine with traditional indigenous cultural practices. As a social worker, I see value in understanding how other cultures help their warriors reintegrate into society. Understanding these practices will allow me to offer veterans a variety of options, enhancing their recovery and allowing them to feel like they have fully returned home.

Already familiar with Western medicine approaches to the causes and treatment of PTS among combat veterans, I sought to identify cultural/indigenous approaches. It was notable that western research tools failed to identify any credible sources regarding indigenous practices for treatment of PTS or the warrior’s return to society. Knowing two veterans who participated in a Rites of Passage Vision Quest in California, I contacted that group and was provided links to educational and government articles highlighting traditional indigenous practices for returning war veterans.  Further searching uncovered an article about Samurai warriors participation in society following war and information on the lifestyle and practices of Assiniboine Native Americans, who were part of the Iron Confederacy in the 1800’s that fought the North-West Rebellion in the region of Hudson Bay, Canada.  I was unable to identify indigenous practices for every continent, but did get a sampling of Native American tribal practices and a historical perspective from East Asia.

Western Medicine

Western medicine is very much rooted in science; it our way of understanding PTS, and the way we justify PTS treatment. While neuroscience has come far in recent years, there is still some way to go.  Science has helped us understand how trauma affects the brain and has identified areas of the brain most impacted by trauma: the amygdala, hippocampus, and prefrontal cortex. Science has also attempted to explain how trauma elicits the symptoms of PTS. “Symptoms of PTS are hypothesized to represent the behavioral manifestation of stress-induced changes in brain structure and function. Stress results in acute and chronic changes in neurochemical systems and specific brain regions, which result in long-term changes in brain ‘circuits,’ involved in the stress response.”  (Bremner, 2006)

Our methods for treating PTS are based in the scientific Western perspective of traumatic brain impacts. Acknowledging the hypothesis that trauma changes chemicals in the brain, some practitioners focus PTS treatment on medication in an attempt to re-balance the brain’s chemical systems. Unfortunately, reports from colleagues and scores of veteran clients indicate this approach alone is not effective at creating long-term stability.  The other primary Western medical approach focuses on talking through trauma so as to process it and repair disrupted neural pathways.  Various methodologies have comparable outcomes, including: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Prolonged Exposure, and Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR). EMDR in particular adheres to Adaptive Information Processing theory, which holds that trauma creates blockages in the neural pathways making it difficult to integrate new or more accurate information. The goal for EMDR is to open those pathways, allowing the brain to heal itself.

Traditional Indigenous Practice

Evaluating the Samurai and many East Asian warriors’ transition back into society revealed two advantages built into their culture. First, Samurai were esteemed members of society, making up only 10% of the population. Coming home from war as a superior class could be enough to ease the transition from combat to civilian life. They were expected to be leaders, as proficient with the spoken word and the brush as they were with the sword and the horse. The second advantage was religion. Zen Buddhism was, and continues to be, the primary practice in much of East Asia. With a religious philosophy of acceptance, mindfulness, and being present in the here and now, East Asian warriors were equipped with practical and spiritual tools to help overcome the effects of war. Indeed, mindfulness practice is used now in American culture to ease anxiety and the effects of trauma.

Looking to this continent, indigenous people have had thousands of years to devise interesting strategies for welcoming warriors home after battle. The Navajo treat warriors who experience PTS with a ceremony called Enemy Way. The ceremony is publicized for several weeks and family and friends are invited. It involves prayer, song, dance, and lasts about a week. “These ceremonies help the Navajo war veterans return to a state of balance, or beauty, within the universe. This state of balance is called ‘Hozho’ in the Navajo language.”  (Native Words, Native Warriors, n.d.). A focused ceremony, lasting for such a long time and recognized by the entire community likely creates a safe, healing space for traumatized veterans. Even practitioners from the Department of Veterans’ Affairs have acknowledged the Enemy Way ceremony and others like it for improving the health and wellbeing of Native Americans who have returned from war.  This welcome seems to provide a Rite of Passage for warriors returning to the community.

The Comanche also have ceremonies for veterans who have endured trauma. Many Comanche today belong to the Native American Church, which combines Christianity with traditional Indian ceremonies.  For some, this includes ceremonies involving the consumption of peyote that has been blessed. The experience seems to help traumatized veterans make sense of their new place in the world.

The Assiniboine Indians held a ceremony immediately upon the return of a war party. Once in sight of their home camp, the war party signaled the loss of members by throwing a robe, rolled into a ball, high in the air. The number of dead was indicated by the number of times the robe was thrown. A delegation went to meet the party and obtain the names of the dead. The warriors were escorted back to camp and word was taken to the relatives of those slain.  Later, they gathered around a ceremonial pipe and talked about their war experience. This ceremonial debriefing seemed to help process traumatic memories and normalize the experience for the warriors.

In all the Native American examples, as with the Samurai, the communities hold their warriors in high esteem.  Indigenous people often ask veterans for advice because of their strong mental ability, a result of overcoming their difficult experiences. Depending on the community, veterans are given special prominence at tribal events. At powwows veterans lead the grand entry of dancers, and are recognized and honored on special occasions with ceremonies and dances that relate their sacrifices to the community.

Even to this day, an accepted Native understanding is that PTS is a “poisoning of the spirit.” The ceremonies and practices are an attempt to cleanse the spirit and help the warrior regain balance.  In Washington state, the Department of Veterans’ Affairs American Lake Hospital offers a Veteran Sweat Lodge, led by an Elder Council of Native Americans to veterans seeking peace and healing.

A Matter of Perspective

While researching this topic, the concept of individualist vs. collectivist cultures emerged. American culture is individualistic; it is common for people to withhold personal stories and experiences from others. In collectivist cultures, individuals share stories with the entire community as a way to help them achieve wellness after trauma. This phenomenon is also common among Israeli soldiers whose cultural roots are steeped in collectivism and are very much part of a community that shares experiences.

“Talk therapy” is the common approach in both cultures. In Western medical practice, addressing one’s trauma is typically done in an isolated office, alone, with a “professional.” Collectivist cultures approach talk therapy in a community or ceremonial way, and this highlights the difference between the two philosophies. Our individualistic approach is incongruent with what we have learned from thousands of years of human history about enduring trauma. It is likely we are focusing on a misguided method. This possibility has profound implications for trauma intervention, warrior reintegration, and social work/clinical practice as a whole.

The Challenge

If the returning warrior is not appreciated for the insight into humanity gained from their combat experience or for imparting that newfound wisdom to the community as a whole, the society’s method of honoring troops is not sincere. While many groups in America claim to honor their troops, that honor is typically done with a bumper sticker, flag, t-shirt, or a “thank you for fighting for my freedom,” rather than a sincere ceremonial, community practice and an attempt to truly understand the traumatic experience of the warrior. The individualistic culture seems to prevent the broader community from reaching out, asking warriors to share their stories.  Rather than leaving space open for warriors to share, or even providing space in the first place, the individualistic community tends to have established specific phrases and objects that allow them to reflect the perceived honor, without actually doing much that requires energy or personal connection with others.

Furthermore, communities that do not adhere to a “communal warrior integration practice” may be doomed to repeat past mistakes. Society assumes the warrior was fighting for the community’s freedom, regardless of the actual threat. Without providing space for the warrior to share their story, this assumption will never be verified, nor will the community ever learn whether the warrior’s experience was justified.

After doing this research, it is clear there are profound reasons that traditional, indigenous and cultural practices must have a place in our current society to help trauma survivors seek wellness, particularly among warriors.  A communal warrior integration practice, combined with Western treatment methods, would make the most impact on a veteran’s wellbeing, acknowledging that both approaches have their strengths and serve a purpose. I have observed combat veterans who are working with us at Growing Veterans (in many ways a communal warrior integration practice), who have also done individual clinical work to process their trauma.  They seem to have the highest sense of well-being compared to others I have come across who have not engaged in either approach, much less both. The two approaches complement each other well. That said, the community could become much more involved in order to amplify this effect.

The challenge is to convince a society founded on individualistic perspectives that communal integration is essential to healing trauma and avoiding its repetition. Western medical professionals must be encouraged to take a closer look at these communal processes - and our community must be provided an example and an opportunity for how they can participate, rather than wave flags on the side line. Fortunately, those opportunities exist with Growing Veterans.

Related Links

About Guest Writer

Citizen Journalist • Member since Jun 15, 2008

To comment, Log In or Register

How Our Community Can Welcome Our Troops Home

By Guest WriterOn Aug 24, 2015

Christopher Brown guest writes how traditional communal warrior reintegration practices could help our returning combat veterans.

Howard Harris Dies - More Testimonials Added

By John ServaisOn Nov 12, 2014

Updated Nov 12. Howard Harris, the founder of the Bellingham silent peace vigil at the Federal Building in Bellingham, has died. He and Rosemary were leaders in our local peace movement.

A Veterans Day Note

By John ServaisOn Nov 11, 2014

On this Veterans Day, a note about how vets need our government to step up - as has never been done. And a personal note on the power of words.

3 comments, most recent 6 years ago

Propaganda

By Richard LewisOn Jun 08, 2014

The poet for the Whatcom Independent back 8 years ago, has accepted our invitation to submit occasional poems to NWCitizen.

Syrian War Perspectives: Jon Stewart

By John ServaisOn Sep 04, 2013

An attempt at linking to one or more writers who can help us make sense of going to war with Syria. An alternative to Kerry-Obama.

We Citizens Get a Say on War

By John ServaisOn Sep 04, 2013

Contacting Rick Larsen and Susan Delbene is actually a viable citizen exercise just now. Tell them to vote NO on bombing Syria.

1 comment, most recent 8 years ago

Riley Covers Anti Syria War Demo

By John ServaisOn Aug 31, 2013

Saturday afternoon - and a rally is taking place in downtown Bellingham against bombing Syria. Riley Sweeny and his Political Junkie site cover it.

To Obama:  No.  Do Not Bomb Syria

By John ServaisOn Aug 30, 2013

Gee, can we make it any clearer? Publisher opinion. So sad that we have to write this to Obama - who got our vote in 2008 because he said we should not have optional wars.

4 comments, most recent 8 years ago

NWCitizen Stands With Edward Snowden

By John ServaisOn Jun 10, 2013

Edward Snowden is a very courageous patriot, in the opinion of the publisher of NWCitizen.

3 comments, most recent 8 years ago

The Plea of Julian Assange

By John ServaisOn Aug 19, 2012

Wikileaks founder spoke from a safe open window to the people of the world. His words are important to the future of democracy and freedoms.

4 comments, most recent 9 years ago

From the Political Junkie: A Sobering Reminder at the Old Settlers Parade

By Riley SweeneyOn Jul 31, 2011

Riley talks about the sobering reminder of our fallen soldiers at the Old Settler’s Parade

2 comments, most recent 10 years ago

Egypt - one writer’s perspective

By John ServaisOn Feb 02, 2011

Egypt - just one citizen voicing his perspective on what is happening. Speaking freely.

4 comments, most recent 10 years ago

Violence was legitimized by Sarah Palin

By John ServaisOn Jan 09, 2011

Sarah Palin’s violence-laced rhetoric shares the blame for the Arizona massacre.

18 comments, most recent 10 years ago

TSA protecting us from terrorists

By John ServaisOn Nov 27, 2010

TSA puts young mother with a bag of breast milk through an illegal and unbelievable process.

5 comments, most recent 10 years ago

The Radical Center and the Outer Limits

By Paul deArmondOn Nov 20, 2009

Did you every wonder what was really going on inside the racist right?

Usually caricatured by stereotypes of bed-sheeted Klansmen and goose-stepping neo-Nazis, the racist right continu

8 comments, most recent 11 years ago

War and Information control

By John ServaisOn Aug 11, 2008

The power of censorship and news control is on display for all who care to look around. Today, the online maps of the country of Georgia have no roads. None. And very little other information. Ju

5 comments, most recent 13 years ago

Benazir Bhutto is dead

By John ServaisOn Dec 27, 2007

9 pm
Some links. Juan Cole has his first take posted regarding the killing of Bhutto. Arianna Huffington knew her well and posted a personal remeberance. CNN reports with some amazing information o

International Justice Clinic

By John ServaisOn Dec 06, 2007

Do we Americans believe in human rights? Do we believe that “all” are equal and have rights as our Declaration of Independence says we believe - or only citizens of the United States? Wednesday this w

Wounded veterans

By John ServaisOn Nov 23, 2007

20,000 Iraq & Afghan veterans with brain injuries are not counted as wounded by the Pentagon. Charming. Not surprising. USA Today has the report in today’s issue. Very nice to see investigative report

Silver Beach forum; today’s war; NSDW meeting

By John ServaisOn Jul 13, 2007

The Silver Beach Neighborhood forum went well last night with about 75 people attending. It was the first public chance for citizens to compare candidates and gauge them for their potential. I could n

{/exp:channel:category_heading}