Topic: Elections (583)

High-paid Campaign Consultants Quench More Than a Thirst for Bellingham Brews

Following the money on the race for the At-Large Bellingham City Council position.

Following the money on the race for the At-Large Bellingham City Council position.

By
• Topics: Elections, Elections,

[Personal disclaimer: Writer Anne Mackie is a donor to and campaign supporter of Russ Whidbee, candidate for the Bellingham City Council At-Large position]

As Bellingham continues to pump out new local breweries, proudly gaining its spot on the craft brew tour maps of the west coast, another industry is tapping into local money. High-paid campaign consultants have acquired a taste for more than just the local brews. A look at the money flowing in the race for Bellingham’s At-large City Council seat between Russ Whidbee and Kristina Michele Martens, reveals there’s a lot of draining going on. 

Under its moniker of “Follow the Money,” the Washington State Public Disclosure Commission (PDCprovides documentation of where campaign money is coming from and where it’s going. A mind-boggling amount of money has been raised by one of the two candidates in this race, Martens, and an equally mind-boggling amount has been funneled by her back out of town. None of this is in violation of campaign funding rules, however, it raises important questions for her local voting constituents to ask. 

As of October 4, Martens’ campaign contributions were $59,398, of which nearly 20% (or $11,540) of the individual non-organizational donations have come from outside of Bellingham, mostly from the greater Seattle metropolitan area. 

Opponent Whidbee had raised approximately one-third that amount at $27,636, of which 3% (or $944) of the individual non-organizational donations have come from outside of Bellingham, mostly from Whatcom county and three from outside of the area. These stark contrasts should highlight concerns for local voters.  

Does money equate a “Win”?

A look back to the 2019 Bellingham election tells us that money does not necessarily guarantee a win. In the mayoral contest between Seth Fleetwood (the victor) he raised $71,557; his opponent, April Barker raised $91,145.

At the level of Bellingham City Council races, the dollars raised are typically lower. In the 2019 race for Ward 1, Hannah Stone (the victor) raised $18,591; her opponent, Beth Hartsoch, raised $18,226. The race between Ward 5 opponents Lisa Anderson (the victor) saw $18,333 versus opponent Chanan Suarez’s $16,937. These are reasonable campaign dollars to raise and spend on a small city’s council races. 

Just two years later the price of participation in the candidacy process for the At-Large two-year position has risen to the level of what it costs to make a down payment on a home: nearly $60,000. While it can be acknowledged that the costs of printing, postage, signage and other forms of old-school advertising have risen in two years, does it rationally explain away Martens’ spending? It would seem that with the advent of social media campaign tools, such as websites and Facebook pages, a more level playing field would open the doors for participation. 

Follow the Money

A deeper dive into Martens’ campaign spending shows that Seattle consultants are doing well in this contest. One consulting firm, Prism West, has been on the receiving end of a large chunk of Martens’ donation money. Its website self-describes: “The Prism West team of ‘Pro-Activists’ brings rich experience, a ‘can-do’ attitude, and a diverse breadth of skills to execute nimble digitally savvy, and design-first campaign strategies.”

Translation: “Digitally savvy” equates to bells and whistles and a big fat bill. Another recipient of Martens’ campaign dollars is Katherine Bobman Consulting in Seattle who is being paid for fundraising services. The nearly $12,000 donated to Martens, thus far, from outside of Bellingham comes with a price tag. Have our small city elections become a source of income for outside consultants? And, is the future of Bellingham’s local city governance to be manipulated from afar? 

Take the “taste test”

As voters prepare to cast their ballots a final flurry of printed propaganda will land in mail boxes – both digitally and on the doorstep – and quickly be thrown in the recycle bin. Hopefully, there will be a short minute of contemplation. Please consider how hard the candidates and their campaign teams have worked to craft their messages to earn your vote. 

Consider the qualifications the candidates present in their Voter Pamphlet statements. Martens: community activist, real estate agent, co-host of TV, radio, and podcasts; founder of the local singing competition Bellingham Idol. Although she states she is a realtor, it appears her license has expired (See Martens' realtor record extract at Attached Files below). Other local work history is difficult to pin down: her Whiskey Productions LLC event promotions company has dissolved (per Washington Secretary of State records). A few months ago she began work with the Chuckanut Health Foundation on its racial equity health campaign. While this most recent career step is admirable, her job qualifications and resume for elected office remain thin. 

Contrast this to Whidbee’s Voter Pamphlet statement and resume: a financial advisor, adjunct faculty at Whatcom Community College and Bellingham Technical College, plus a mile-long list of 40-years of local community service. His is a thick resume with a thinner, more typical stack of campaign dollars. 

As my introduction disclosed, I am endorsing and have financially donated to Whidbee’s election campaign. I took the “taste test” afforded us through the Public Disclosure Commission. He is by far the most qualified, time-tested, and credible candidate. He may or may not do well at karaoke…I do not know; but I do not evaluate a candidate based on performance talent.

With its breweries, beauty, parks and livable neighborhoods our small city on the bay is no longer a secret. We do not want to also gain a reputation as a whistle stop on the political consultants’ opportunist train.

Attached Files

About Anne Mackie

Posting Citizen Journalist • Member since Aug 21, 2016

Comments by Readers

Bill Geyer

Oct 08, 2021

Anne,

Thank you for your research, important points noted, and I share your concerns.  The latest total expenditure reports for Candidate Martins = $18,500 spent on campaign management or fundraising out of $37,774.76 expenditures reported to date.  49% spent on campaign staff salaries instead of voter outreach, not a comforting trend.  https://www.pdc.wa.gov/browse/campaign-explorer/candidate?filer_id=SKINK—227&election_year=2021

Candidate Russ Whidbee reports only $10,232.26 to date, no staff salaries.  That tells me Mr. Whidbee has a group of volunteers that believe in his qualifications.  Three young men doorbelled my street, well informed, energetic, polite, a pleasure to meet.  Mr. Whidbee will has the support of this household.  

Read More...

Anne Mackie

Oct 08, 2021

Bill,

Thanks for providing this additional information. It’s certainly part of the big picture the voters need to understand. 

Read More...

Karen Steen

Oct 08, 2021

Martens arrived in Bellingham only three years ago with a media background. Her agenda is ideological and she openly declares her intentions for a career of higher elected office. Ideology, charisma, ambition and outside money characterize divisive party machine politics. The numbers confirm it. Thanks, Anne, for following the money.

Read More...

Ginger Decker

Oct 10, 2021

We’ve always been a city of unity and proactive efforts to make Bellingham one of the most livable and healthy cities.  

I am concerned that outside interests want to influence Bellingham elections.  Martens efforts and now her well funded campaign have been focused on exposing Bellingham’s “shortcomings” without an understanding of decades of community efforts that have made Bellingham an environmentally conscious and socially tolerant place to live. 

An outsider mistake to divide and conquer us. 

Anne, you’ve done a great job exposing the money flow from and back to Seattle.  Thank you!

Read More...
To comment, Log In or Register

High-paid Campaign Consultants Quench More Than a Thirst for Bellingham Brews

By Anne MackieOn Oct 08, 2021

Following the money on the race for the At-Large Bellingham City Council position.

4 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Letter: Eddy Ury Support

By Letter WriterOn Oct 07, 2021

Judith Akins writes about her choice for Whatcom County Council.

Vote Russ Whidbee For The At-Large Seat Of The Bellingham City Council

By Dick ConoboyOn Oct 05, 2021

Russ is a decades-long resident of Bellingham. He knows our city much better than most and his record proves it.

12 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Ranked Choice Voting Always Beats Winner-Take-All

By Stoney BirdOn Sep 29, 2021

Voting on a karaoke song contest offers an opportunity for a clear view of Ranked Choice Voting

1 comment, most recent 1 year ago

Today’s Cascadia Weekly Gristle is Spot On: Mayor Called Out for Dismissive Attack

By John ServaisOn Sep 01, 2021

Mayor Fleetwood spent 10 minutes verbally attacking Tip Johnson’s petition to stop illegal city street vacations.

2 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Ranked Choice Voting Gaining Support From Left and Right

By Stoney BirdOn Aug 26, 2021

Friday, August 6, was the monthly Art Walk in downtown Bellingham. Kit Muehlman and I were asking people to ...

1 comment, most recent 1 year ago

County Council Plays Politics With Our Judges

By John ServaisOn Jul 21, 2021

The Whatcom County Council is afraid to make an appointment of a temporary District Court judge before the Primary Election. Is the “fix” in?

1 comment, most recent 1 year ago

The Census: Protecting Privacy versus Creating Useless Data

By David A. SwansonOn May 18, 2021

“Differential Privacy:” A statistical adjustment system that may render 2020 census population data unusable.

1 comment, most recent 1 year ago

Ranked-Choice Voting – Let’s Keep It Moving

By Stoney BirdOn Feb 12, 2021

Current legislation, moving forward in Olympia, would permit localities to adopt ranked-choice voting as an upgrade to their currently mandated top-two system.

1 comment, most recent 1 year ago

Gene Knutson to Retire from Bellingham Council

By John ServaisOn Jan 12, 2021

Gene Knutson today announced he will not run for reelection this year and is retiring from the Bellingham City Council.

8 comments, most recent 1 year ago

The Same Door - Six Hours Apart

By John ServaisOn Jan 07, 2021

Two photos of the same door, one taken about 2 p.m., the other six hours later at about 8 p.m., on Wednesday, January 6, 2021.

10 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Drilling Deeper into Whatcom County: Covid-19 & Political Orientation

By David A. SwansonOn Nov 19, 2020

In the three Whatcom County school districts carried by Trump-Pence the covid-19 infection rate is 1.4 times higher than found in the 4 districts carried by Biden-Harris.

3 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Stop the Lying, Doug

By Michael RiordanOn Nov 17, 2020

State Senator Doug Ericksen parrots baseless Republican Party claims about non-existent voter fraud in the 2020 presidential elections.

8 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Did Trump Help Democrats take the 2020 election in Washington?

By David A. SwansonOn Nov 15, 2020

As is the case, nationwide, it appears that Trump assisted Democrats in carrying the 2020 presidential and gubernatorial elections in Washington

2 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Did Trump Help Democrats take the election?

By David A. SwansonOn Nov 07, 2020

Trump advocated behaviors that placed his followers at higher risk to being sickened and even dying from covid-19. Did a reduction in republican voters aid in the election of Joe Biden?

1 comment, most recent 2 years ago

Ballot Drop Boxes: Auditor Drops Opportunity

By John ServaisOn Oct 31, 2020

Diana Bradrick, our elected Whatcom County Auditor, leaves two ballot drop boxes in storage rather than install them in Bellingham - where they are needed.

8 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Voting: Thoughts on Some Election Choices

By John ServaisOn Oct 19, 2020

Some candidates and issues can be a bit obtuse as we look at the campaign literature. These recommendations are for those with progressive, liberal, or moderate values and perspectives.

4 comments, most recent 2 years ago

The Last Stand

By David A. SwansonOn Oct 17, 2020

Only four US counties remain covid free, each of them rural. We discuss how the pandemic reached rural, isolated counties.

15 comments, most recent 2 years ago

Letter: Supporting Ferndale School Levy

By Letter WriterOn Oct 13, 2020

Satpal Sidhu supports Ferndale School Levy