Topic: Environment (365)

Geneva Cell Tower Protest

Board member acknowledges illegal contract

Board member acknowledges illegal contract


About 30 concerned citizens marched to the Lake Whatcom Water and Sewer District (LWWSD) Operations Office at 1010 Lakeview Street to protest building a cell phone tower. I wrote about that proposal in this article and I was among the protesters. This is an update highlighting what happened.

Protesters were at the site for almost two hours and were visited by LWWSD board member Todd Citron, whom I would like to thank for showing up and engaging with us. Todd acknowledged that the contract LWWSD signed with DISH was illegal because public hearings that were supposed to have taken place, were ignored. He expressed his concerns about having alienated the community and assured us that LWWSD values us. Still, he made no firm commitments to stop construction or terminate the contract with DISH.

Electromagnetic radiation near towers may cause cancer.

Protesters pushed for solid commitments and shared their concerns about the tower. Todd said that since they had signed a contract with DISH, although an illegal one, he wanted to see what could be done that would be in the best interest of all parties. I question why Todd seems so concerned about an illegally signed contract.

Todd said DISH approached the LWWSD board and, without consulting the community or any broadband experts, they made a decision about our welfare after listening to a skilled salesperson from a special interest. The board was apparently convinced they could sidestep the normal process.

I don’t mean to paint a totally bad picture of this situation. The community rallied, organized, and united against this cell tower. Todd acknowledged that the board made a mistake. The result is that we will, finally, have the public hearing we were supposed to get in the first place. This time, we must push for a real commitment from the LWWSD board.

I must say I am proud of this group and our community. Many of our members have engaged the County Council, LWWSD, and the community at large. I hope LWWSD will prove they want to be a benevolent part of this community by tearing up their illegal contract with DISH and refusing to entertain this idea moving forward.

As many of you know, I have for years been asking the county to form a proper Broadband Advisory Group. Not groups like the City and PUD/Port have that are made up of big telecoms representatives and sympathizers. We need a group made up of citizens, specifically citizens not connected to special interests who can provide objective perspectives on broadband, cellular, and other technology-related issues. With the exception of council members Tyler Byrd and Kaylee Galloway, the County Council has blown this idea off.

About Jon Humphrey

Citizen Journalist • Bellingham • Member since May 23, 2017

Comments by Readers

Liz Marshall

May 18, 2022

This is great! Fantastic community effort, good acknowledgement by Todd Citron, clear post by writer, hope for future tearing up of illegal contract, expectations set for ethics in government transactions.


Dianne Foster

May 18, 2022

It was also discussed yesterday that the group (Whatcom Citizens for Safe Technology) has access to a New York lawyer who has an 85% track record in fighting cell towers.   Hopefully,  if the Council recognizes that moving forward without a public hearing was illegal,  a lawsuit won’t be necessary.


Jon Humphrey

May 20, 2022

Thanks everyone. Here is an e-mail I sent to LWWSD and our elected officials citing the article “We Have No Reason to Believe 5G is Safe” from Scientific American.”
With our public institutions hell bent on using our fees and tax dollars to protect the rights of non-living made up people like DISH and other corporations, it seems prudent to share the article “We Have No Reason to Believe 5G is Safe” from the well respected, peer reviewed, magazine Scientific American.
You see, I know how this works. DISH, Verizon, T-Mobile, Comcast, etc. have a direct line to our governments while the citizens get no real representation. However, the law is largely all about reasonable doubt, and there is more than enough reasonable doubt about the safety of wireless technology. 
The industry, like DISH, uses industry funded studies just like big tobacco did to try to claim that its products are safe. However, there now exists a large body of evidence showing otherwise. 
Hence, you have a duty and legal obligation to act on behalf of your citizens to protect them. This is called the “precautionary principle” in legal terms. It also gives LWWSD and the County a clear path to deny the permitting of building this tower. In fact, it means you were negligent in how you handled the building of previous towers in the county recently too. 
So add this to the many other legit reasons you’ve been given that this tower at 1010 Lakeview St. is a bad idea.

To comment, Log In or Register

Geneva Cell Tower Protest

By Jon HumphreyOn May 18, 2022

Board member acknowledges illegal contract

3 comments, most recent 8 months ago

CityView Appeal Window Has Closed

By Dick ConoboyOn May 07, 2022

The baton has been passed to the developer to perform on this private dormitory complex. We shall see…

Letter: Local Governments and the Environment

By Letter WriterOn May 03, 2022

Liz Marshall writes about her concerns of our local governments and their environmental actions

Highway Robbery

By Jon HumphreyOn Apr 24, 2022

Or how supposed progressives in our state legislature work against clean energy and the environment

14 comments, most recent 9 months ago

The Problems WTA Electric Buses Don’t Have

By Jon HumphreyOn Apr 15, 2022

“Alarmist” article is unfair to needed new technology

3 comments, most recent 9 months ago

Hip Hip Hooray for the Herons!

By Jamie K. DonaldsonOn Apr 01, 2022

Twenty-two years, hundreds of volunteers, thousands of hours, their own lawyer, and the herons won!

8 comments, most recent 9 months ago

Agent Orange and Vietnam Veterans, Their Children, and Grandchildren

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 22, 2022

Agent Orange is the “gift” that keeps giving.

3 comments, most recent 11 months ago

No Project Too Absurd

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 12, 2022

CityView is an oversized, misplaced, unnecessary, and virtually unadaptable apartment complex.

4 comments, most recent 11 months ago

You Can’t Manage What You Don’t Measure

By Eric HirstOn Feb 02, 2022

Irrigation water usage in Whatcom County is estimated, and Eric puts forward reasons why we need meters to accurately measure usage.

No Commitment To Sustainability = No Votes

By Jon HumphreyOn Jan 24, 2022

Vote No On The Bellingham Public School 2022 Facilities Bond to Protect the Environment

15 comments, most recent 11 months ago

Electric School Buses #2

By Jon HumphreyOn Nov 14, 2021

Bellingham Public Schools Learns Evasive Maneuvers from City Hall

12 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Greenwashing 101: School District Touts Electric Vehicles

By Jon HumphreyOn Oct 30, 2021

Replacing all 71 buses would cost $6,035,000. Maybe later…

17 comments, most recent 1 year ago

One Last Chance for Permanent Protection for the City’s Great Blue Herons?

By Jamie K. DonaldsonOn Oct 21, 2021

 After twenty years of fits and starts, there is a time-sensitive opportunity for the city of Bellingham ...

11 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Not a Single Damn Tree? Really?

By Alex McLeanOn Oct 10, 2021

And our long-term approach to climate change is…?

4 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Save the Trails Referendum Falls Short

By Tip JohnsonOn Sep 09, 2021

A summary of the Douglas Avenue right-of-way petition effort.

The Scheme to Turn Green-Spaces into $Green

By Tip JohnsonOn Aug 17, 2021

Neighborhoods beware: City Hall is selling our public rights. Your neighborhood could be next.

14 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Bellingham: Beware!

By Guest WriterOn Aug 11, 2021

Guest Writer David Donohue explains Sunnyland’s experience with City Hall’s promises, code enforcement, and follow-thru.

7 comments, most recent 1 year ago

City Throws Down the Gauntlet

By Tip JohnsonOn Aug 09, 2021

But ever so s_l_o_w_l_y

3 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Our Public Property Rights For Sale - Cheap!

By Tip JohnsonOn Jul 27, 2021

Preserve public property rights & save the trail

14 comments, most recent 1 year ago