Recent Articles

Rise of Medicare Advantage – Creation of a Myth

Millions of Medicare recipients have already been schnookered into Medicare Advantage. Don’t be a victim. Fight back.

Millions of Medicare recipients have already been schnookered into Medicare Advantage. Don’t be a victim. Fight back.

By

Update 3/14/2023:  A reminder of the PSARA webinar on Monday, March 20, 5:00 p.m. (PDT) - “Don’t Let Naked Profiteering Destroy Our Medicare” featuring Dr. Ed Weisbart, Missouri chair and national board member of PNHP (Physicians for a National Health Program), Assistant Professor of Clinical Medicine at Washington University, St. Louis, 2004-2021.  See registration announcement at FILES below or click HERE to register directly.

 

[Our Guest Writer, Rick Timmins,  is the Co- Outreach Vice President of the Puget Sound Advocates for Retirement Action (PSARA) and leads the PSARA Whidbey Island Committee. He is a retired veterinarian and educator.  This article originally appeared in the March 2023 issue of The Retiree Advocate, a monthly publication of the PSARA Education Fund and is reprinted here in its entirety with the permission of the publisher.]

John Ehrlichman, an advisor to President Richard Nixon, had an interesting  discussion with him about changes being considered for Medicare. Ehrlichman described the Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) business model to Nixon: “All the incentives are toward less medical care, because…the less care they give them the more money they make.” Nixon’s reply: “Fine.” This led to a major change in the trajectory of Medicare.

Passage of legislation in 1972, 1973 and 1997 gradually introduced the concept of for-profit health care corporations, such as HMOs, to what was originally a non-profit public program.  Part C was added to parts A and B of Medicare, and was called Medicare+Choice. When it was renamed Medicare Advantage (MA) in 2003, the systematic privatization of Medicare began. 

At first glance, MA might seem like a good deal. The monthly premium is low or non-existent for most plans. Co-pays for most services are less than Traditional Medicare (TM).  MA plans tout more services such as vision, hearing, dental and gym memberships (depending on the plan). Most MA plans include Part D (prescriptions). MA has a cap on out-of-pocket expenses (up to $8,300 for 2023And, celebrities tell us it’s wonderful. What’s not to like?

 Let’s start with how MA companies make a profit. In TM doctors and other providers are paid for the services they render (Fee For Service) by Medicare. In MA, Medicare pays private insurance companies through “capitation,” at a rate based on the number of patients in their system and the severity of their medical needs (identified by codes). Additionally, companies are rewarded with bonuses based on a complex system of benchmarks, bids and quality incentives. The capitation system incentivizes insurance companies to provide less care in order to make more profit. How do they do that? 

Limit access to care. MA plans control costs through a network of physicians, hospitals and other providers with whom they contract for services at a set price. Beneficiaries are restricted to that network, limiting the choice of providers. The extra services offered by some MA plans (vision, hearing, dental) are minimal, and restricted to specific contracted providers, who are often difficult to access. By limiting choices and access, the insurance companies make more profit.

Deny and delay care. Unlike TM, MA beneficiaries are required to receive pre-authorization (PA) from the MA plan for diagnostic procedures or referrals to specialists or for certain drugs. In a survey of physicians by the American Medical Association in 2021, 93% reported delays in the care of their patients due to PA. Ninety one percent (91%) said it had a negative impact on outcome, and 34% report that the requirement for PA has resulted in serious consequences for their patients. In the AMA survey, 82% of the physicians reported that patient frustration with the delays caused by PA can lead to patients abandoning their treatment, which reduces costs to the insurance companies.

In 2018, the Department of Health & Human Services, Office of Inspector General (OIG) investigated whether  MA plans would boost revenue by denying access to coverage. Indeed, the OIG found that 13 percent of denied prior authorization requests and 18% of payment requests that were rejected would have been approved under fee-for-service Medicare. Millions of beneficiaries were illegally denied necessary care.

Game the system.  The code submitted to Medicare describes the severity of a health issue. By intentionally changing the code to one that indicates greater severity (“upcoding”), MA insurance companies can raise the amount that Medicare will reimburse them. MedPac (a nonpartisan agency that advises Congress about Medicare issues) reported that in 2020, total Medicare payments to MA plans averaged 4% more than to TM, even though MA plans spend 10 to 25% less per beneficiary. The Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) released a summary of audits of payments to just a sample of MA insurance companies, revealing $12 million in overpayments (many due to upcoding), averaging $1,000 per beneficiary. The total cost to taxpayers is much higher, since this is a limited sample. CMS has estimated net overpayments to Medicare Advantage plans at $11.4 billion for 2022. If no changes are made to the system, and this trend continues, the Medicare Trust Fund could be depleted by 2028. 

          Myth: Medicare Advantage offers lower cost and higher quality health care than Traditional Medicare.

          Fact: Medicare Advantage is a duplicitous scheme to increase the profits of insurance companies through denial and delay of health care and submission of fraudulent data to Medicare. 

Myth: Medicare Advantage will save Medicare money.

          Fact: Medicare Advantage costs Medicare more than TM, through excessive administration costs, profits, and fraud. It will hasten the depletion of the Trust Fund.

Future articles in the Advocate will expand on just how dangerous privatization of health care can be.  

End of Article -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[NB:  There will be a PSARA webinar on Monday, March 20, 5:00 p.m. - “Don’t Let Naked Profiteering Destroy Our Medicare” featuring Dr. Ed Weisbart, Missouri chair and national board member of PNHP (Physicians for a National Health Program), Assistant Professor of Clinical Medicine at Washington University, St. Louis, 2004-2021.  See registration announcement at FILES below or click HERE to register directly]

Attached Files

Comments by Readers

David A. Swanson

Mar 06, 2023

I wonder if there is a difference in satisfaction levels between those who have a medicare advantage plan with an insurance company or a group of private practive physians, on the one hand, and those who are members of a not-for profit healthcare provider’s advantage plan ( such as Kaiser Permanente), on the other hand? I cannnot speak for the former, but I can say that as a member of one of the latter’s advantage plans I have not encountered the problems listed and I would rate my experience as highly positive.

Read More...

M. Lynda Hanscome

Mar 06, 2023

“not for profit” providers’ (REACH) and medicare advantage both rip off both patients and Medicare; just at different intersecting points.  They may say “not for profit” but I would seriously question those words.  It is Patients OR Profits and the minute any private entity gets involved, it is all about Profits.

Read More...

Dick Conoboy

Mar 06, 2023

David,

A valid question and I don’t have the answer.  Perhaps there have been some studies but I just don’t know.

That being said, satisfaction can be a measure but behind that is the question of how the Medicare money is being spent regardless of the client experience. The patients might not be aware that they are being shortchanged.  If funds are being siphoned off by the medical provider, that means less availble for other Medicare recipients. 

Read More...

Carol Follett

Mar 17, 2023

 Thank you for this information on an utterly confusing situation! I have registered for the workshop. I cannot attend the one you have provided, Randy, so I hope it will be recorded and we can hear it later. Do you know if that will happen. If it will be uploaded for us, would you give us that link too. 

Read More...

Randy Petty

Mar 17, 2023

Carol, I don’t know if it will be recorded, but they do have a You Tube channel showing previous webinars.
“Hosted by KFF, The Health Wonk Shop features conversations with experts delving into timely health policy issues for deeper discussions beyond the news headlines.”     ( KFF = Kaiser Family Foundation)
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLBfqBziFkXIfxoh3fCwpV0tJbJT4XP5zA

Read More...

Rise of Medicare Advantage – Creation of a Myth

By Guest WriterOn Mar 06, 2023

Millions of Medicare recipients have already been schnookered into Medicare Advantage. Don’t be a victim. Fight back.

6 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Call To Action On Medicare (Dis)Advantage!

By Dick ConoboyOn Mar 02, 2023

If we do not speak out NOW on the privatization of Medicare, the system will effectively be eaten alive from within.

3 comments, most recent 1 year ago

NWCitizen Journalist Down, But Certainly Not Out

By NWCitizen ManagementOn Feb 28, 2023

Stoney Bird, local writer and activist, was severely injured in a fall at this home. He has helped many. Now it is our time to return the support.

3 comments, most recent 1 year ago

A Cruel Joke From The VA and Congress

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 27, 2023

At least with a real joke, you get to laugh. Here, the government seem to laugh at you.

7 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Atul Explains Vote Against Jail Recommendations

By Guest WriterOn Feb 24, 2023

Atul Deshmane explains his dissenting vote on the new jail recommendation report of the Stakeholder Advisory Committee to the County Council

9 comments, most recent 1 year ago

TAGNW Recaptured By Big Telecom

By Jon HumphreyOn Feb 22, 2023

With the loss of Michael Gan, TAGNW has become a puppet organization of big telecom that is aggressively working against the public interest.

4 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Never Too Late to Shout About It

By Gene MarxOn Feb 14, 2023

Gene Marx is a Vietnam Veteran and past National Board of Directors Secretary of Veterans for Peace. A retired Federal Administration employee, Gene lives in Bellingham, Washington, with his wife Victoria.

17 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Females And Football

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 11, 2023

Actually, it is Exploitation Day all around.

3 comments, most recent 1 year ago

“Social Security And Medicare Are Off The Books Now”

By Dick ConoboyOn Feb 09, 2023

This is a quote from President Biden during his State of the Union address on February 7th, 2023. Your bullshit meter ought to be in the red now.

7 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Secret Conversations

By Jon HumphreyOn Feb 08, 2023

How Democratic Party Leaders and Elected Officials Are Abusing “Signal” to Have Secret Conversations about Public Topics

5 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Traditional Medicare - The Promise Is In Peril

By Guest WriterOn Jan 31, 2023

Excellent and succinct overview of Traditional Medicare, now under a very real threat. People are now waking up!

4 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Public Banking Bill Introduced In Olympia

By Dick ConoboyOn Jan 27, 2023

Public funds belong to all the residents of Washington state. Why give that money to private banks so they can make a fortune for themselves?

5 comments, most recent 1 year ago

The Impression of Progress on F-Street

By Jon HumphreyOn Jan 23, 2023

Public Works successfully gave the impression of progress, without actually having to bother

Hillsboro’s Public Fiber Success Could Be Ours, If We Push

By Jon HumphreyOn Jan 05, 2023

Hillsboro Oregon’s higher median income and lower cost of living could be ours if we push our public officials into public fiber internet.

Our Throw-Away Military Service Personnel

By Dick ConoboyOn Dec 26, 2022

Holiday Greetings to the troops. A middle finger.

10 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Oath Keepers and Stolen Valor

By Dick ConoboyOn Dec 07, 2022

The tab created by the risibly-named Oath Keepers was stolen from the U.S. Army. It is an insult to every Army veteran, especially those qualified as Ranger or Airborne.

2 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Did Proposition 5 “Cure” Its Way to a Win?

By Guest WriterOn Dec 05, 2022

Is the passing of Prop 5 a genuine reflection of the will of the people of Whatcom County? John Marshall guest writes.

9 comments, most recent 1 year ago

Medicare Part C - The “C” Is For Crap

By Dick ConoboyOn Nov 27, 2022

Part C is really for sh*t but that word does not start with a “C.”

2 comments, most recent 1 year ago

No Responses

By Jon HumphreyOn Nov 20, 2022

A running Record of the Zero Transparency Policies of the PUD, Port, County and City Councils From 1/12/2022 Onward

6 comments, most recent 1 year ago

A Civilian Speaks To Veterans

By Dick ConoboyOn Nov 11, 2022

A must-read for anyone who knows a war veteran… and anyone who never met one.

10 comments, most recent 1 year ago