Recent Articles

The Thanksgiving Surge: How Fared Whatcom County?

Public health experts issued more than a few warnings about the danger of gatherings over Thanksgiving and although the surge in Covid-19 cases they expected nationwide took place, it was not as high as expected in some areas, such as Wisconsin. To these areas one could add Whatcom County. In addition, one could also add Benton county, which I use as a comparison because of its many similarities and, importantly, one relevant Covid-19 difference, political orientation, which likely has contributed to the latter having far more Covid-19 cases than the former.

In looking at the effect of Thanksgiving on Whatcom County and how it fared compared to Benton County, I used data from the “Github” archive provided by the Johns Hopkins Corona Virus Resource Center for two 17-day periods. The first 17-day period represents the run-up to Thanksgiving, November 7th to 24th and the second, the post-Thanksgiving period in which the surge, if any, would occur, November 24th to December 11th. If the Thanksgiving surge occurred one expects the latter period to show a higher increase in cases than the former period. If political orientation continues to play a role, one would expect the Thanksgiving surge to be higher in Benton County.

In the 17-day run-up to Thanksgiving, Whatcom County’s Covid-19 case count increased by 30.34%, from 1,694 on November 7th to 2,208 on November 24th, a difference of 514 cases. In the 17-day post-Thanksgiving period, its case count increased by 28.35%, from 2,208 on November 24th to 2,834 on December 11th, a difference of 626 cases. So, while there was a higher case count in the latter period, it was not as high as would have been the case under a scenario where they increased by 30.34% or higher, which would have led to 2,878 or more cases by December 11th. In this sense, Whatcom County can be added to the areas where the surge was not as bad as expected.

Benton County followed a path similar to Whatcom. In the 17-day run-up to Thanksgiving, its Covid-19 case count increased by 29.15%, from 5,808 to 7,501, a difference of 1,693 cases. In the 17-day Post-Thanksgiving period, its case count increased by 27.48%, from 7,501 to 9,562, a difference of 2,061 cases. As was the case in Whatcom County, there was a higher case count in the latter period, but it was not as high as would have been the case under a scenario where they increased by 29.15% or higher, which would have led to 9,688 or more cases by December 11th. In this sense, Benton County also can be added to the areas where the surge was not as bad as expected.

With an estimated 2020 population of 228,000, Whatcom County has approximately 22,000 more people than Benton County. However, Benton County has about 3.4 times more Covid-19 cases as of December 11th, 2020: 9,562 v. 2,834. As pointed out earlier, the “Republican” political orientation of Benton County and its disdain for basic protection measures such as mask-wearing and social distancing is a likely contributor to this difference. However, the fact that Benton County is now posting lower relative increases in Covid-19 cases is a sign that these attitudes may be changing, something that might be be due to the efforts of General James Mattis, USMC Ret, - who was born in Pullman (Whitman County) and raised in Richland (Benton County) - to “de-politicize” basic public health measures. Perhaps his efforts have also led to wider acceptance of these same measures in northeastern portions of Whatcom County, which share a political orientation in common with Benton County.

Comments by Readers

Nicholas Sotak

Dec 13, 2020

David, do you think shifting your window a week to the right on both side of Thanksgiving would give a better idea of what the holiday’s effect was? 

Presumably we wouldn’t see infections that happened on, or in the few travel days leading up to, the holiday materialize until at least several days after the holiday. Further, the carry-on effects from those new infections may not be captured until closer to two weeks (or more) post-holiday.  Maybe it wouldn’t make a difference in this case (presuming there wasn’t actually much of a holiday surge), but I’d be interested to know if you chose the window with this in mind.


Ray Kamada

Dec 13, 2020

Regarding Covid, Whatcom’s done twice as well as the rest of Washington. And Washington’s done more than twice as well as the US. Meanwhile, to avoid lockdowns, some still argue for the chimera of herd immunity, which will never happen for reasons I’d need another thread to detail. Yet, we still omit  one big issue - the many tens of $ millions we lost when Canada closed the border, due to the US having an oomtude more covid infections per capita than Canada. E.g., Whatcom’s relatively low rate is still twice BC’s.

That is, our Port Authority spent $40 million upgrading Bellingham Airport, mostly to accomodate travelers from BC. Where’s our return on that investment? Poof! And how about the Costco relocation and upgrade? Poof! Not to mention Bellis Fair, Bellingham and the rest of our downtowns, along with hundreds of satellite businesses, all suffering from the pandemic, plus the border shutdown it  induced. Poof!

Local economists and political scientists at Western who read this blurb might consider scrounging some grant  money to do a proper case study. How much money did we really lose, locally, to promote death and protect  our precious freedom (from accountability)? 


David A. Swanson

Dec 14, 2020

Hi Nicholas,

In terms of the pre and post-Thanksgiving time peirods, I kept  the folllowing factors in mind: (1) incubation period and changing guidelines on it per changing guidelines on quarantine periods; (2) having a sufficient number of days to make up a period so that we could actually see meaningful change, if there was any; (3) having the same number of days in  the pre and post periods; (4)  not comparing apples and oranges so to speak by keeping the two periods in the same (Fall) season;  (5) being awaqre of  peak travel days associcated with Thanksgiving (Per quotes found at “Elite Daily,” the  “Washington Post” and elsewhere about the busiest travel days ...” the busiest day according to flight demand is the day before Thanksgiving, Wednesday, Nov. 25, with the second busiest day being the Friday before Thanksgiving, Nov. 20. Return flights are a bit more spread out, but the Sunday following the holiday, Nov. 29, is looking to be the busiest post-holiday travel day,which lines up with last year’s data.”); and (6) given that the PSAs on following basic public health precautions by Mattis appeared to have started in June, I thought that if his efforts were succesful among those disdainful of mask-wearing and social distancing,  they would be observed by the start of the pre-Thanksgiving period - this was an important consideration in comparing  Benton County (once again)  to Whatcom County.   Given these factors, my interest in exploring the Thanksgiving surge and Christmas/New Year surges as two separate events and getting something about the former out before we moved into the latter period, the pre and post-Thanksgiving dates I selected seemed a reasonable choice.

Hi Ray,

Even the Swedes are acknowledging that their “herd dimmunity” approach has not worked ( ) 


Ray Kamada

Dec 14, 2020

Yeah, Anders Tegnell, the head of Swedish Public Health is rapidly becoming persona non grata in Sweden. Ten times the case and death rates of their neighbor nations, yet their economy fared no better. That’s failure with a big F!

So, that opens the other thread. And that is, compared to simply masking up, vaccination, and/or mass, at-home, rapid testing and quarantining, as was recently implemented successfully in Slovakia (pop. 10.2 million), striving for natural herd immunity makes no sense for several reasons.

1) As in Sweden where more than 500 doctors and nurses have recently quit, due to sickness and burnout, the sheer number of covid cases quickly overwhelms hospital capacity. So, perhaps soon in parts of California and other states, ICUs will max out, staff shortages will run amuck, and people will start dying in their homes, in ambulances, and in hospital hallways. Then come the freezer trucks and mass grave sites, as happened in New York City last May, and we’ll lose count again.

2) The herd immunity enthusiasts seem to think covid outcomes are binary: either you die or you get well. And since few people actually die, let’s save the economy instead. WRONG! Three times as many patients become permanently disabled as die. Almost everyone who goes to the ICU and survives comes back diminished, because, rather than just a lung disease, covid is more a vascular disease that can attack any organ, e.g., your heart and your brain. So, ensuing mental illness, including hallucinations and psychosis, is a common feature of covid. Now imagine freeway driving. Thus, compared to short term savings, what’s the long-term, economic and societal cost  of having millions of disabled and diminished capacity people shuffling around? I’m not sure and neither is anyone else, but the answer isn’t simple.

3) The whole concept of natural herd immunuty is simplistic because we now know that  80% of infections are due to superspreaders at larger gatherings. Meanwhile, even if 70% of the populace gets infected, the pandemic won’t die out quickly because most prudent people will continue to mask and self-isolate. That means isolated pockets will keep getting infected, occasionally, long after nominal herd immunity levels have been reached. Moreover, it will never be entirely safe because, being a corona virus, immunuty is quite likely to be only temporary.

4) Even so, if people got  vaccinated en masse and got yearly booster shots, it would render this discussion entirely moot. But they won’t because many people are naturally suspicious, in a way that beckons superstitious faux remedies. Might not be PC to say that, but that’s the way it is. So, rather than wiping out the virus completely, we’ll have lingering pockets of occasional infections, such that covid will become another of those haphazard, hazards of life, like the flu, but worse, a lot worse.

Meanwhile, let’s just hope SARS-COV-2 doesn’t mutate into something even more dangerous.


David A. Swanson

Dec 14, 2020

Hi Ray,

Per your insightful comments, it is of interest that the COVID-19 pandemic appears to be following its own “epidemiological transition. “ It first appeared as an “acute” population health condition early in 2020. Currently, it appears to be transitioning into a “chronic” population health condition. It will be important  to understand this transition along with its long-term demographic consequences, particularly in regard to composition and the components of change.

 Regarding the acute phase,  modeling and understanding even simple aspects of a pandemic was challenging because of the sparsity and quality of data, particularly in local areas. This was unfortunate because it is in local areas where many battles are being waged against locally occurring outbreaks. Tnis is why I explored standard, readily available and easily applied demographic methods and perspectives in the initial articles I did for NWC. The next steps in terms of research will be to conduct  ex post facto tests of accuracy and utility.

In regard to the second phase, the transition of COVID-19 into a “chronic” population health condition, one must bring to bear more advanced tools to conduct a  review of the current status of the pandemic and projected course in selected areas and move on to cover the characteristics of the disease and why it is a pandemic. After discussing some measurement issues ( See,e,g.,     or ), 

it wouild be useful to describe morbidity/mortality data in selected areas. Following these descriptions, one could move on to define health disparities, describe the types of health disparities and examine the correlates of demographic attributes with them and examine the relevance of the disease on population composition and health-related behaviors. This could be followed by considering the likely implications of COVID-19 on the future demographic make-up of selected areas ivia observed relationships and trends including impacts on demographic composition and vital events (especially births and deaths.

Even if we would have had a competent executive administration in D.C. and a population less susceptible to mis-information, consipriracy theories, and irrational propaganda, this virus would have presented tough challenges. In the absence of such an administration and population, we ended up, to paraphrase a lyric in  John Mellencamp’s Walk Tall, with “the simple minded and the uninformed being easily led astray….,” which has served to bring into sharper focus the fact  that “somewhere out in the distance is the death of you and me.”


The Thanksgiving Surge: How Fared Whatcom County?

By David A. SwansonOn Dec 12, 2020

Public health experts issued more than a few warnings about the danger of gatherings over Thanksgiving and although the surge in Covid-19 cases they expected nationwide took place, it was [...]

5 comments, most recent 7 months ago

Comcast Rate Hike: Getting Less for More

By Jon HumphreyOn Dec 11, 2020

Comcast is raising the rate on your service by $3/month for most customers starting on your next bill. Their promos state, “This has required investment in our high-capacity network, which [...]

4 comments, most recent 7 months ago

The Face of the Planning Commission on January 1st

By Dick ConoboyOn Dec 08, 2020

The Planning Commission is probably one of the most important of all the city’s commissions and boards. The commission reviews and makes recommendations on the city’s Comprehensive Plan [...]

4 comments, most recent 7 months ago

The Douglas Avenue Trail

By Guest WriterOn Dec 02, 2020

Daniel Kirkpatrick guest writes. He lives in the Happy Valley neighborhood and is one of several community leaders on the south side who are respected and supported by most residents.[...]

3 comments, most recent 7 months ago

Dirty Deal at Douglas and 21st

By Tip JohnsonOn Dec 02, 2020

Update Dec 8: Last night the Bellingham City Council did not give final approval to the street vacation request, but sent it back to the Hearing Examiner for further review. I [...]

10 comments, most recent 7 months ago

Nervous About the Vaccines? Don’t Be

By Deb GaberOn Nov 28, 2020

Are you a little anxious about how they’ve rushed some vaccines through at the fastest rate in human history? Maybe concerned about whether less than a year was enough [...]

4 comments, most recent 7 months ago

False Fast Speeds, Bad Connections, & Broken Promises

By Jon HumphreyOn Nov 24, 2020

I recently received the data on a part of the Bellingham school network, pictured above. You should note up front that the schools block all independent testing of [...]

If Campers Had Housing, They Wouldn’t Be Camping

By Guest WriterOn Nov 23, 2020

Douglas Gustafson guest writes, with assistance from Lisa E. Papp. Doug is Chairman of HomesNOW! Not Later, an all-volunteer nonprofit organization operating in Bellingham and Whatcom County. HomesNOW operates Unity [...]

4 comments, most recent 8 months ago

The Big Lie of Republican Environmental Values

By John ServaisOn Nov 21, 2020

This article in today’s Huffington Post, Trump Swiftly Blows Up His One Decent Conservation Action, is both stunning and devastating. Last August, President Trump signed a multi-billion dollar public [...]

2 comments, most recent 8 months ago

Just Dying To See The Family?

By Dick ConoboyOn Nov 20, 2020

The answer is, “Don’t!” That holiday smooch might be the kiss of death. The perfect storm is about to play out, not only in Whatcom County but nationwide. As [...]

Shop Local and Shop Early

By Guest WriterOn Nov 19, 2020

Chuck Robinson guest writes. Chuck, with his wife Dee, founded Village Books and Paper Dreams in Bellingham’s Fairhaven district in 1980. Since passing on the business to three staff members [...]

Drilling Deeper into Whatcom County: Covid-19 & Political Orientation

By David A. SwansonOn Nov 19, 2020

This article is co-authored with Matt Cropper, Zoran Stojakovic, and Eric Tyberg. We thank Mike Mohrman and Tom Kimpel for technical assistance. Swanson and Tyberg reported earlier that nationwide, counties [...]

3 comments, most recent 8 months ago

Stop the Lying, Doug

By Michael RiordanOn Nov 17, 2020

LEST WE FORGET, a certain state senator from the northern reaches of Whatcom County played a bit part in bringing the current excuse for a president into the White House. [...]

8 comments, most recent 8 months ago

Did Trump Help Democrats take the 2020 election in Washington?

By David A. SwansonOn Nov 15, 2020

This article is co-authored with Eric Tyberg, a retired IT executive and consultant residing in Lincoln, California. Originally from Falun, Wisconsin, he rose through the ranks at IBM and formed [...]

2 comments, most recent 8 months ago

Armistice Day

By Dick ConoboyOn Nov 11, 2020

Yes, today is Armistice Day, November 11, 2020. It was established to commemorate the day the armistice was signed in 1918 that ended World War I. As it has morphed into what is [...]

13 comments, most recent 8 months ago

The 100 Acre Wood Shakedown

By John ServaisOn Nov 10, 2020

Update:  On Wed eve, Nov 11, the forest district commission voted to keep the 2021 levy the same at 28 cents.  A follow up article will posted in a few days.​[...]

13 comments, most recent 8 months ago

Bellingham: 21st Century Community or Small Town Backwater?

By Jon HumphreyOn Nov 09, 2020

As I was writing this article, fellow writer Dick Conoboy forwarded me a notice from the City of Bellingham saying CenturyLink was asking for a modification to their TV franchise [...]

4 comments, most recent 8 months ago

Did Trump Help Democrats take the election?

By David A. SwansonOn Nov 07, 2020

This article is co-authored with Eric Tyberg, a retired IT executive and consultant residing in Lincoln, California. Originally from Falun, Wisconsin, he rose through the ranks at IBM and formed [...]

1 comment, most recent 8 months ago

Veterans’ Heavier COVID Casualties

By Dick ConoboyOn Nov 05, 2020

[This article has been written in anticipation of Veterans Day on November 11th, next Wednesday.] Just as they did during their military service, our veterans are carrying a burden of [...]

Ballot Drop Boxes: Auditor Drops Opportunity

By John ServaisOn Oct 31, 2020

Two very large ballot drop boxes are sitting on the floor of a Whatcom County storage room - and have been for weeks. Auditor Diana Bradrick has decided not to [...]

8 comments, most recent 8 months ago